A flashpoint in the 3rd Congressional District mini-debate on TPT’s Almanac program Friday (video) was Republican candidate Erik Paulsen’s charge that DFL candidate Ashwin Madia has illegally coordinated his campaign with the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, an independent group. Madia denied it and challenged Paulsen for proof. State Rep. Paulsen produced from his breast pocket a Madia campaign press release, which he said mirrored “exactly almost word-for-word” the DCCC’s own ads.
Read a transcription of the heated exchange after the jump. Also, see the Madia press release — and the DCCC’s own press release that predated Madia’s by a month and a half.
Here’s a transcription of the exchange between Paulsen and Madia on TPT:
PAULSEN: I’ll tell you, he is coordinating his attacks with the DCCC, and that’s wrong.
MADIA: Erik, that’s a strong allegation, and I hope you have some proof of that because that’s absolutely untrue. [On camera, Paulsen begins to pull out a piece of paper from his breast pocket.] What I’d say is, the allegations that you made against me, about, you know — the entire negative campaign that you’re running — you want to talk about phone calls [to independent groups asking them to stop running negative ads], you ought to call your campaign manager and tell him to pull those negative ads if that’s what you want.
TPT’S ERIC ESKOLA: Is there something in the ads you want to set the record straight on?
MADIA: No, I’m going to keep focused on the economy and the people in the 3rd district and getting this nation moving again –
TPT’S MARY LAHAMMER: Okay, Rep. Paulsen, you have something dramatic it looks like you want to –
PAULSEN: I just want to say I have a press release that came right out of the Madia campaign that exactly mirrors the exact DCCC ad they’re running against me to smear my record. Exactly, almost word for word. And so there is coordination. A phone call can be made.
LAHAMMER: And you’re denying these allegations because that’s not allowed, as we know. Right? [Unintelligible: You know(?)] the law.
MADIA: Absolutely. On the one hand, it’s funny he’s telling me to pick ‘em [the phone] up and call them. On the other hand, he’s accusing me of breaking the law. Look, the truth is, of course there’s no coordination. Absolutely not. And I hope you have more than a press release to back that up, Erik, because that’s a very strong allegation.
PAULSEN: It’s got your communication director’s name right on it.
Paulsen’s charge is indeed serious: Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty’s election campaign paid a $100,000 fine for coordinating with an independent group in 2002.
Here’s the Sept. 15 Madia for Congress press release that Minnesota Public Radio’s Curtis Gilbert dug up, which Paulsen presented Friday on TPT as evidence of the Madia campaign’s alleged coordination with DCCC ads. And here’s a July 31 DCCC press release in which the DCCC appears to have itself first raised the charges that it repeated in ads mailed to voters in late September, according to KSTP-TV, which gave the ads an “F.”
The two releases do share identical phrases and even sentences, but whether that constitutes coordination is another question. Both cite as a source the same July 22, 2008, report attributed to National Public Radio (NPR) report — which seems actually to have appeared on NPR rival American Public Media’s “Marketplace” program (relevant part starts at about 24:00):














7 Comments »
Comment posted October 12, 2008 @ 11:51 am
Is Paulsen claiming once a Congressional Committee issues a release, the campaign can’t follow up with another one?
That’s what his complaint sounds like to me. I see no evidence of coordination.
Comment posted October 12, 2008 @ 3:39 pm
Using the same phrases doesn’t at all constitute coordination. How many times have you heard Paulsen recite the same exact things from the anti-EFCA ads? How many times as Coleman said the exact same thing from NRSC spots?
It’s a stupid distraction trick by Paulsen to keep stories in the media (and independent media) off of the issues and onto who’s coordinating what. And it’s working, I guess.
If there was a real allegation of coordination, it’d be filed with the FEC, not TPT’s Almanac to make the allegation actually legitimate.
Comment posted October 12, 2008 @ 5:17 pm
It doesn’t matter of the DCCC issued the first press release on the subject or not. The fact that Madia issued a press release with almost the exact same wording as the DCCC, is a stong indicator that they are coordinating their messages. Although more importantly it shows that Madia was lying when he said that he has nothing to do with those proven false attacks on Erik Paulsen. He was throwing the exact same mud. There is no getting around it, Madia is not running the honorable campaign that he promised us.
Comment posted October 12, 2008 @ 10:46 pm
There is no getting around it, Paulsen is not running the honorable campaign that he never promised anyway.
Can anybody tell me the last time Erik Paulsen appeared in a public forum with the voters without his surrogates to babysit the event.
How can Erik expect to win a congressional seat without even talking to the voters directly? What is he hiding?
Comment posted October 12, 2008 @ 10:52 pm
Erik has nowhere else to go. He has clearly decided not to speak to the issues important to middle class families, and the voters will handle the rest. Puzzling I must say, although I’m no longer complaining.
Madia: The Courage to Change
Comment posted October 13, 2008 @ 8:28 am
Paulsen is now becoming the melodrama queen…give me a break. Campaigns use information they get from many sources and it certainly isn’t coordinated. I don’t see how restating information from a public press release (everyone else had it) is coordination…I would say that’s citing a source. This is just another diversion from Erik and his mentors to try and not debate on the issues…something it looks like the voters will never see, as the moderators so far in any of the debates or interviews seem unwilling to try and pin down Erik on any policy or voting stances. Madia, for his part, looked, acted and sounded Congressional as the other two took shots at the LEADER….yes, Erik, you are getting your rear end handed to you and it’s obvious you don’t like it. Try talking to the voters instead of hiding behind Rammer and making baseless charges…we deserve better from an elected official.
Comment posted October 13, 2008 @ 8:37 am
And another thing, if you read the Madia campaign press release, all it does is cite numerous questionable donations to Paulsen’s campaing (including those from the Vegas event) and this is all public information…what exactly is the big deal? Let’s get back to the issues and solutions…I guess that means we need to listen to Ashwin Madia as he’s the only one talking to the voters EVERY DAY about what’s really important to our district and country!
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL
Leave a comment