How Did Minnesota’s Members of Congress Vote in 2006?

By Andy Birkey
Monday, March 05, 2007 at 2:30 pm

The National Journal has released its yearly vote ratings, which score key Congressional votes on a continuum of liberal and conservative and assign a percentage to each member of Congress. For instance, U.S. Rep. Betty McCollum, D-Minn., has an 87.7 percent more liberal voting record than other members of Congress, whereas 2nd District Republican John Kline has an 80.3 percent more conservative voting record than other members of Congress. Since 1981, the ratings have ranked members of Congress on economic issues, social issues, and foreign policy.

Here’s how Minnesota’s delegation stacked up:

Name, Party, District Liberal Rating Conservative Rating
Betty McCollum, D-4th 87.7% 12.3%
Martin Sabo, D-5th, 82.2 17.8
James Oberstar, D-8th 78.3 52.3
Jim Ramstad, R-3rd 52.3 47.7
Collin Peterson, D-7th 51 49
Mark Kennedy, R-6th 34.8 65.2
Gil Gutknecht, R-1st 26.2 73.8
John Kline, R-2nd 19.7 80.3
Sen. Mark Dayton, D-Minn. 81 19
Sen. Norm Coleman, R-Minn. 46.2 53.8

While it gives some idea of voting ideology, the percentile ranking can make some members of Congress seem more moderate than they actually are. According to MyDD:

It’s worth noting that because the National Journal rankings deal in percentiles rather than hard numbers, a particular Senator might appear more moderate than he or she deserves credit for. For instance, Norm Coleman’s 53.8 conservative score would seem to put him not too far out of line with his Minnesota constituents, but a gander at his party unity and presidential support scores — 77 and 88, respectively — paints a different picture: one of a Senator too beholden to his party’s leadership. Similarly, Susan Collins comes off well in the National Journal rankings with a score that actually places her in the left half of the Senate, but her party unity (66) and presidential support (79) scores indicates she’s not quite the centrist maverick you might assume she is.

Follow Andy Birkey on Twitter


Categories & Tags:

Comments

No Comments

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.