Rep. Michele Bachmann’s comments that she believes Barack Obama “may have anti-American views” and that the media should investigate whether members of Congress are “pro-America or anti-America” has done more than fill the coffers of her Democratic challenger, El Tinklenberg: it’s prompted a challenge for her congressional seat from within the GOP. The St. Cloud Times reports that Aubrey Immelman, Ph.D., a professor of political psychology at St. John’s University and the College of St. Benedict, registered yesterday as a write-in candidate. On his campaign site, Immelman references Bachmann’s words to Chris Matthews:
And, as if incumbent Rep. Michele Bachmann’s enthusiastic support for these policies is not damaging enough, she now appears to be calling for a witch hunt to “find out [which members of Congress] are pro-America or anti-America.” We cannot tolerate this festering brand of neo-McCarthyism in our midst.
He sees himself as an “alternative for disillusioned Republicans.”
“The Republican Party needs to rebuild its image, and this cannot be done when its elected representatives say these kinds of things,” he told the St. Cloud Times’ Larry Schumacher.
While Immelman garnered only 14 percent of the vote in the Republican primary, his entry may shave off support from Bachmann, who last week lead DFLer Tinklenberg by just four points, according to a Democratic party poll.















32 Comments »
Comment posted October 19, 2008 @ 2:13 pm
How dare Bachmann try to label domestic terrorism as anti-american. Domestic terrorism is an important institution, its as wholesome as apple pie. That’s why I will be supporting Immelman, he has the integrety to embrace arrogant unrepentant terrorists and also understands the importance of hiding from the american people these types of associations and will stand by our right to have no idea who our politicians are associating themselves with. (unless they are republican of course).
Comment posted October 19, 2008 @ 2:31 pm
We live out of state and are making a campaign donation to a man we’d never heard of prior to Friday: Elwyn Tinklenberg. If we had lived in Minnesota, I would be despondent about her being my representative. As a country, we should all be alarmed. I think Ms. Bachmann needs a good history lesson, and a good boot out of office.
Comment posted October 19, 2008 @ 2:33 pm
Having lived thru the McCarthy years, I know how this kind of hate tracks thru society. Soon the finger that points at congress will include members of the press, filmakers, writers, etc.
I am also appalled that she, as well as sarah Palin, seems to include those who support better education as “leftists!”
Are Rebublicans not interested in the fact that US education lags in the world, and that 30% of students fail to graduate from high school?
But even more troubling is the idea that any critism of US issues, policies, direction would be seen as unpatriotic, or un-American.
Been there, done that. Now we face severe challenges to American leadership in the world, and economy at home. We must look forward, not back.
I am an independent, and have always been so. George Washington was right. Country first means to me that we should be loyal to what is best for America and not loyal to Party politics. I will vote for Obama bcause he is addressing the current challenges and issues in a meaningful way.
As an independent voter I can do so without fear that I will lose my job, or be accused of being disloyal or “Anti-American.”
We should all thank the Founding Fathers for ensuring our votes are not made public.
take care
Kathy
Comment posted October 19, 2008 @ 2:56 pm
I think this is very courageous by Immelman who did NOT want to be put into a spoiler roll and WAS going to wait until the end of October to check the polls, but he DETESTS the Bachmann/Bush neocon agenda and wanted to give an alternative before. This McCarthy anti-American Bachmann rant drew him out. It puts him in a very UNLOVED position by Republicans and Democrats.
Send Aubrey some $love$, he used $5000 of his own money in the primary. He’s got stones, if he switches to Democrat, we could use some Democrats with Stones!
http://www.immelman.us/contribute/
Comment posted October 19, 2008 @ 5:45 pm
Bye bye, Bachman! Guess you’ll have to high tail it to Canada as you threatened to do on Chris Matthews’ show.
I’m in California, but please Minnesotans–Get this woman out of office.
Comment posted October 19, 2008 @ 5:57 pm
McCarthyism was one of the most despicible elements of 20th century America on the homefront. Modern McCarthyites need to be rejected by the public no matter which party they belong to. Vote against Bachmann to honor America’s founding ideals of fairness, inclusiveness and tolerance.
Comment posted October 19, 2008 @ 7:05 pm
Michele Bachmann is a scary combination of extreme fundamentalism and nationalism….hard to believe this exists in the state of Minnesota.
Comment posted October 19, 2008 @ 7:57 pm
**Are Rebublicans not interested in the fact that US education lags in the world, and that 30% of students fail to graduate from high school?
But even more troubling is the idea that any critism of US issues, policies, direction would be seen as unpatriotic, or un-American.
**
Actually both parties want better education, but have different plans and viewpoints on how to accomplish it.
And Bachmann is not stating that criticism of US issues or people is unpatriotic. What has been said though is that domestic terrorists that like to bomb the pentagon are anti-american. I find it really messed up that you (and everyone else here) would disagree with that position.
Comment posted October 19, 2008 @ 7:58 pm
Michele Bachmann hates America, supports terrorism, and worships the devil. There are many rumors that she molested two children, rumors which she has never answered.
Comment posted October 19, 2008 @ 7:59 pm
**Michele Bachmann is a scary combination of extreme fundamentalism and nationalism**
Yeah shes really extreme. She condemns domestic terrorism and approves of american values, what an extreme radical she is.
Comment posted October 19, 2008 @ 7:59 pm
Who the hell is Audrey Immelman? I’ve been voting republican in this state for 30 years and I’ve never heard of her.
Listen, you frantic libs: Michelle Bachmann was wrong. Obama isn’t a socialist. He’s a Marxist. “Spreading the wealth around” is just a 2008 version of “from each according to his ability, to each according to his needs.” – Karl Marx.
And when Crissy Mathews indignantly asked her who else in congress is un-American, rather than name names, something which she could have easily done, starting with all those who opposed the war, she deferred to the press, suggesting they do their job. I’m outraged at the press’ outrage.
Comment posted October 19, 2008 @ 8:35 pm
Michele Pond Scum has less chance of getting elected than McLame does.
Comment posted October 19, 2008 @ 8:53 pm
Thank you Ms Bachmann, you have given me another Congressional Race to watch with interest.
Likely the 1 and 500,000 people in the state who is not nice and she gets elected to Congress, unreal?
Frankly I would ask her to change her state of residence, forget being in the congress representing your great state.
In all my years traveling there I have always been impressed with how kind and polite people are, this women is not. Did she forget to take her med’s or something?
Comment posted October 19, 2008 @ 9:18 pm
that is nice — republicans throwing each other under the bus. i doubt the any of anti-bachmann(r) windfall of money is going to mr. immelman(r).
Comment posted October 19, 2008 @ 10:12 pm
“Are Rebublicans not interested in the fact that US education lags in the world, and that 30% of students fail to graduate from high school?”
Yes, Republicans are interested in education, but in the inverse way you would expect: the more ignorant the American public is, the more easily they can ride roughshod over the nation and scare people into voting for them.
An educated electorate means a Republican Party in exile.
Comment posted October 20, 2008 @ 12:12 am
Salem, Civil War, Women’s right, WW II, Red Scare, Civil Rights… all have one thing in common: FEAR. We are afraid of the unknown, the unjust and simply, we are afraid that what we know is wrong. So we created the fear factor to justify our believes, our ideology. It is sad that a country as advance as ours is incapable to learn the errors of our past.
Comment posted October 20, 2008 @ 2:29 am
DumpBachmann is correct. I was tracking the polls (see partisan poll results below) and waiting for an independent poll prior to the Oct. 28 write-in filing deadline before deciding whether to mount a write-in campaign as requested by a number of supporters.
I was not going to enter the fray if the Bachmann-Tinklenberg spread was even close to the margin of error. When Rep. Bachmann made her shameful remarks on “Hardball,” when the average of three polls put the race at Bachmann 42%, Tinklenberg 33% (see table below), I decided that the time was right.
divisionary: You’re correct; the anti-Bachmann money is going to Tinklenberg, not Immelman.
Bachmann Tinklenberg Anderson Und
Grove Insight (Aug. 19-21) 40 27 NR NR
Grove Insight (Oct. 10-12) 42 38 NR 15
Pblc Opn Strg (Oct. 12-13) 44 33 8 NR
Mean 42 33
As to why I am running, see the links below:
http://www.immelman.us/news/write-in-candidacy-announcement/
http://www.immelman.us/news/on-the-campaign-trail-day-47/ (Statement on Iraq War)
Aubrey Immelman
Comment posted October 20, 2008 @ 5:13 am
For Bob the Bilderburger.
I expect a lot of grousing from folks like you who can’t have their way anymore.
Push back sucks doesn’t it Bobby?
As an Independent it’s kinda refreshing to see the vile posion your party spews questioned and held up for the light of day.
And it’s Aubrey. Read the story next time Babs, er. Bob.
Comment posted October 20, 2008 @ 6:52 am
One can already see the McCarthyism popping its head up in a few comments here…by intimating, for example, that one is “un-American” for opposing the Iraq war. Wow. Dear Mr. Bilderburger (huh? Bilderberg Group – are you scamming?), while I respect your right to hold your own views about the war, as Americans, we don’t all have to agree on it. I know, I know…radical idea. We don’t all have to agree. (Hmm. Isn’t that what this country was founded on?) Wishing you the best.
P.S. The world is changing big time right before your eyes. I invite you to come along for the ride. It truly is an amazing feeling…and one that will probably put a big smile on your heart.
Comment posted October 20, 2008 @ 7:09 am
Well, Dr. Immelman, while you’re at it, bring Rep Bachmann to task on this one:
“They’re bringing in disease and violence and every sort of difficulty,” she said of illegal immigrants. “We need to protect ourselves against that.”
That was from Thursday’s 6th District debate
From the St. Cloud Times
http://www.sctimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=2008110170035
Last time I heard someone complain about “they’re bringing in disease” I don’t believe it was about human beings.
Comment posted October 20, 2008 @ 9:27 am
Michelle Bachmann is a lunatic. Pure and simple.
Pingback posted October 20, 2008 @ 9:51 am
[...] driven Aubrey Immelman, who was defeated by Bachmann in the Sept. primary, to announce he’s running as a write-in candidate so genuine conservatives have someone to cast their vote for in [...]
Comment posted October 20, 2008 @ 10:58 am
It’s important that voters feel comfortable with an alternative to Bachmann. Many in her district didn’t know the details of her scummy beliefs because Patty Wetterling ran a positive campaign and Bachmann is a “Political Christian.” You know the type–always holding themselves out as holier than everyone else until you take a close look and discover it’s because they have something to hide.
There are some very interesting personal and family issues with Michelle, just as there are with Norm Coleman. Her assaults against others are designed to keep people from looking closely at who SHE associates with and what SHE believes. It’s worked so far, but she may have gotten just a little too cocky and let her mask slip a little too much. I’m not a big Tinklenberg fan, but I donated and hope he ends Bachmann’s miserable political “career.” She has a fake law degree from an unaccredited school and has never held a real job, and her husband (wink, wink) cures homosexuals for a living.
Comment posted October 20, 2008 @ 12:06 pm
I’m an ex-Republican who DETESTS Bachmann and her allegiance to Hastert-Cheney-Rove who all campaigned for her. Bachmann’s antics with Bush2 have been embarrassing.
Bachmann has done NOTHING for MN06 but be on TV.
It has been a looong time since I sent any money to a Republican but I am going to ENJOY this!
http://www.immelman.us/contribute/
OK, Please, post/repost
Comment posted October 20, 2008 @ 12:34 pm
ultraplops@yahoo.com, is it possible for you to be more dense? No one believes there’s anything good about domestic terrorism, and I haven’t seen any support here for your suggestion anyone does. You incorrectly believe Obama is friendly with and consorting with a former domestic terrorist, and now you and that crazy woman are suggesting all Democrats in Washington hate America — though I suppose that isn’t new from you people. Bachman isn’t whipping up lunatics like you because she loves America; she’s doing it because her failure of a party is about to get its butt handed to it and she sees all the power they’ve been able to abuse the last eight years slipping from their grasp.
I think it’s hilarious that she was one of the few Republicans who had a decent shot at maintaining her post and she swooped in at the last second to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory. This only cements the prevailing sentiment that, in this cycle, Republicans are STUPID, STUPID, STUPID.
Comment posted October 20, 2008 @ 2:05 pm
“ultraplops@yahoo.com, is it possible for you to be more dense? No one believes there’s anything good about domestic terrorism, and I haven’t seen any support here for your suggestion anyone does
“”
Let me explain this again and maybe you can pick your head up out of the sand for a couple seconds.
Bachmann at no point called anyone anti american except for people like Ayers. Now Ayers, is a self admitted domestic terrorist who has done things such as bomb the pentagon. Any rational human being I think could call that anti-american. People like you however, are jumping down her throat calling her every name in the book. Maybe I am a lunatic, I really don’t understand it.
“”and now you and that crazy woman are suggesting all Democrats in Washington hate America”"
And you called me dense! She never said that. Even when asked directly she didn’t say that. You better listen to the interview again. Its like liberals only hear what they want to hear.
And for the record, I would never suggest that either.
Comment posted October 20, 2008 @ 2:32 pm
It’s amazing all this talk of Obama being anti-American and associating with terrorists. When Bush after 9/11 let all the Bin-ladens free passage out the proverbial back door. After 1000’s of American’s dead, that to me seems pretty Anti-American. Why not start the investigation with Bush.
Comment posted October 21, 2008 @ 7:18 am
Note to all the people pretending that Bachmann was talking about “domestic terrorists”.
Bachmann was asked: “How many people IN THE CONGRESS OF THE UNITED STATES do you think are anti-American?”
She answered: “I wish the American media would take a great look at the views of THE PEOPLE IN CONGRESS and find out, are they pro-America or anti-America?”
Pretending that she was talking about “domestic terrorists” isn’t going to fool anyone.
Comment posted October 21, 2008 @ 9:17 am
**Pretending that she was talking about “domestic terrorists” isn’t going to fool anyone.**
Did you listen to the whole thing? Shortly before the quote you just mentioned, Chris asked her specifically who she thought was anti american. She stated people like Ayers were(a self admitting domestic terrorist). So yes she is talking about domestic terrorism when she is talking about anti-americanism. She was asked specifically whether members of congress where anti-american and she re-itereted that people like Ayers were.
The quote you have there was her stating that she wanted to know IF members of congress had similar views.
Comment posted October 21, 2008 @ 5:29 pm
I saw M. Bachmann on Hardball last week. I never heard of her before this interview. Right after the show I Googled her campaign and found Mr. Tinklenberg’s website and donated right away, even though I can’t vote for him. I can’t vote for him from Hawaii. Good Americans don’t need fruitcakes in Congress. I’m glad many other Americans don’t want fruitcakes in the Congress, proof, look how many other Good Americans donated like me. Good luck Mr. Tinklenberg. Beat that FRUITCAKE!
Comment posted October 25, 2008 @ 4:33 pm
Wow, the hate-spin machine is in full force here! Most of you have strayed so far from the facts about what was said that there’s not a shred of truth left. Michele IS a Christian, a real Christian. She raised her children and many foster children in a loving, safe, intelligent way. Her husband is a legitimate counselor with a thriving business. She’s just like most of us in the 6th, except that her experience as a tax lawyer gives her some expertise above many of her collegues.
I don’t know why you all think you have the right to insult this woman, calling her all sorts of negative things and attacking her on all levels of her life.
Michele exposed a dirty little secret about congressmen and senators who hold un-American views on government and anti-American views when it comes to free markets and taxes. If you yourself are a Marxist or a socialist or a communist, of course you are angry with Michele because she dared to expose your favorite people as the frauds they are. I mean frauds because they say they will uphold the constitution and our form of government, but then they vote for things that move our country ever more toward socialism and beyond. They are American Frauds and I thank Michele for suggesting the press actually investigate them. (How about as closely as they are investigating Gov Sarah Palin?)
Apparently the thought police only attack those who think like the Founding Fathers. God rest their souls.
Comment posted November 3, 2008 @ 7:04 pm
It is always nice to see that someone has enough BALLS to speak the truth in a world full of lies….
and it’s usually a woman!
Go Michele…I appreciate your candor and work for Minnesota’s 6th District!
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL
Leave a comment