It was a tear-filled room at a meeting of the Health, Housing and Family Security Committee as senators heard testimony about how medical marijuana had helped loved ones live in less pain during the last few days of their lives. But after those tears, the hearing devolved into a strange round of testimony as opponents pulled out all the stops to blame marijuana for higher crime rates and the downfall of the family, and one testified that medical marijuana is a scheme by billionaire George Soros to make drugs legal.
Dr. George Wagoner, a physician in Virginia, Minn., broke down as he described the trials he and his wife suffered as she struggled with ovarian cancer. They had tried Marinol, a prescription made of synthetic THC, one of the more than 60 active compounds in marijuana.
After the couple tried everything, they turned to friends after hearing about medical marijuana. Soon after, a bag of marijuana mysteriously appeared on their doorstep. After smoking a small amount, he said his wife “experienced sudden and complete relief from her nausea.”
Choking back tears, he said, “Eating lunch isn’t a big deal until you can’t … The relief was as complete and dramatic as any I’ve experienced in my practice.”
Joni Whiting described how marijuana helped her daughter, a wife and mother of three, deal with the pain of cancer during the last days of her life.
“I can tell you with conviction that I would have no problem going to jail for acquiring medical marijuana for my suffering child,” said Whiting. “The law is unjust. And I would have rather spent the rest of my life in prison than have denied her the medicine that kept her pain at bay and allowed her to live 89 more days.”
She spoke of her family, their service to the country (Whiting is a Vietnam veteran and one of her sons recently completed an 18-month tour in Iraq) and her reluctance to allow an illegal drug in her home. “What would you have done had you been in my shoes?” Whiting asked. “Could you sleep at night when your child was screaming in pain?”
Kathy Rippentrop spoke of her mother, who used marijuana when she suffered debilitating pain as a result of cancer. “Two puffs, two minutes, and the violent sickness was totally gone,” she said. “An hour later, Mom was able to have a good meal. The stomach problems from the chemo were totally gone. It also helped her regain a quality of life that allowed her to continue to fight.”
But those moving stories were contrasted by the testimony against medical marijuana.
Tom Prichard, president of the Minnesota Family Council, took criticism of the bill to an extreme. “This bill would allow 18-year-old boys to grow marijuana in their homes without any outside supervision,” he said. “My reading of the bill says it would prevent landlords from regulating the growing and use of marijuana on their premises.”
He continued, “This bill would allow marijuana dispensaries to set up shop across the state, in homes and storefronts on main streets and neighborhoods and apartment buildings. Why? The only reason I can see is that it is to legitimize, frankly, the broader acceptance of marijuana in the community’s eyes.”
James Stinziani, who said he was part of the “LaRouche operation,” said that the push for medical marijuana was simply a conspiracy drawn up by billionaire George Soros. “What is happening here — if anybody is familiar with George Soros — he is pretty much supporting and funding the major drug operations in the United States.” He accused medical marijuana supporters of being in league with Soros.
But legislators weren’t buying it. The bill passed the committee by a voice vote of 8-3.
Sen. Yvonne Prettner Solon, DFL-Duluth, countered the opposition testimony. “We’re not talking about getting people hooked on drugs and then going out in the street and, you know, destroying their lives and passing it on to other people. We’re talking about end of life issues — a last resort for people’s suffering.”














15 Comments »
Comment posted February 12, 2009 @ 10:51 pm
Not only should they not buy into the lies told by the idiot Prichard they should go after him for perjury. How many families have been destroyed by incarcerating peole for possessing a plant? The Minnesota Family Council is an ugly joke. Come on Minnesota pass a pro medicine law that lets people grow their own and use waat is one of the best natural medicines we have!!!
Comment posted February 13, 2009 @ 5:07 am
Its a plant right?
Its natural? I heard the FDA cant pass a pill for approval unless its 100% chemical. It can have NO organics in the pill. Did you know that? Thats why they dont prescribe 100% organic or natural pill form, it HAS to be CHEMICAL? AInt that a little bit strange to you? So now, one thing on this earth that is natural, and we should be able to consume under our OWN legitamate well being, they say we CANNOT? I dont think the government know whats right for us a a people. Take DIGITAL TV for example? What the Heck? DIGITAL TV?? wow thanks. Give USPS a day off What is wrong with us? I heard the term GOING POSTAL before? I mean wow. Lets make some real choices here people, were a young nation, in the great graph of the timeline, we havent really been here much at all have we?
Now Shouldnt it be my RIGHT to consume WHATEVER THE HELL I WANT TO CONSUME IN MY BODY? Why NOT? IS IT HURTING YOU? FOR REAL??? Oh that cig smoke is WAYY TOO MUCH FOR YOU HUH? Second hand garbage. I dont believe a single word of it. Either you got a good immune system, or you dont, or your diet is all messed up, or your natural rock. Or your a depressed pill popping maniac on a schedule of drugs to get you right. Who knows how much harm these FDA approved pills or Paid Advertisement pills sold at the local walgreens are really worth or whats is contained herein. Thats complete garbage how they could do that to us. But this one thing that is all natural babe, and you cant deny it, we are denied of. Why the HELL do they ALLOW cigs to be made and taxed on but but not this friggin plant. It says IN GOD WE TRUST on our bills. What? whos idea was that? I thought we were all insignificant pieces of waste matter blobs of flesh walking around consuming, wasting, ecologically hyperventalating our land and country and people to the extreme until we find ANOTHER solution to the SAME problem and talking a whole heap of CRAp but cant back it up with a single ounce of a correct cure. I could care less about NASA, Mars, Jupiter, Lost trillions of dollars rumsfeld, the HALDRON COLLIDER or whatever the hell those scientist wanna blow thier money on. I thought it said in that book the bible dont look to the heavens for the answer or something like that, its right in front of us type of thing. Then poof. We found the answer to life, but were not telling you haha naner-naner-naner.
What the hell are they doing to us man. Economy is wrecked, people are angry, theyve failed me for years. I hate it man. For real. But you say, if you hate it so much, why dont you go live in Iraq right? You say, “if its so friggin bad, go live on an island off africa, hunt your food and never pay taxes again. HA. Life goes on……The top banks get Millions, while we as the people get a 100 stimulus check. Thanks. I dont want a stimulus, stimulate me, move me, make me feel Im in a great country and realize marijuana is just that, a plant, you either like it or you hate it. Period. If you have an addiction, Youre weak. Get over it. Life is short. I would be happy forever if it was legal. Who wouldnt be? Seriously. I dont know why they are whining like little spoiled children hating this planet called earth. I dont know what gives them the power to say I cant smoke this green plant if I want to, its rude, and hateful of them, jealousy maybe, cause deep down, maybe they cant handle it. Some people cant comprehend the thought of something new, and indifferent. But not too long ago friends, this pure thing that grows out of the soil WAS legal. Some dopehead caveman found out millions of years ago, thousand years ago, whatever who cares when/who first smoked it, I just care WHEN they made it ILLEGAL. WHY? Why are you depriving me of this world while Im alive, you shouldnt have the power to do that to me, I sure the hell wouldnt do it to you. Alcohol, haha. big deal. Ciggarettes. haha big deal. GET OVER IT. ITS NATURAL IT GROWS FROM THE EARTH WHAT THE HELL WHY IS IT ILLEGAL I DONT UNDERSTAND THE POINT HERE WHAT THE HOLY COW MAN WOW WHY. I dont know why we pour billions of dollars back into failing businesses, and unto ourselves from this MAGICAL bank of money. I dont understand that either. OMG anyway. WOW. If you dont like it, move out huh. USA. USA. Yay. USA.
I dont get it. But I still love ya, and everyone and everything in this world. But I just dont like ways we do things nowadays, it seems so wrong and there are alot of ways we can do publicly, and internationally, to raise the morals and views and livelyhood of our world and people but sometimes we take the wrong steps and initiative. Like my post here. But whatever, I’m not gonna erase it cause my fingers hurt from all this BS and I try to hide it inside, but in this rude anonymous totally wrong type of way I show it. But I keep waiting for something really good to happen for us, but I understand Im the only one who can do it for myself is myself. Blah blah blah. happy valentines day jane, I love you.
Comment posted February 13, 2009 @ 12:22 pm
Its a plant, I looked into moving out of the country a few years and ago and there is nowhere to go. They won’t let us in. That being said, I don’t know why they didn’t just show the film Reefer Madness at this hearing. They would have got the same information and those testifying wouldn’t have had to commit perjury.
Weed is no different than alcohol. I don’t use either, but it is time to stop this insanity and legalize and control and tax marijuana. What a joke.
Comment posted February 13, 2009 @ 1:05 pm
If Pawlenty does veto and blocks access to one of the “least toxic therapeutic substances known” (to quote DEA Judge Francis L. Young’s conclusion about marijuana as medicine), I hope his career takes a nose-dive.
It is obvious this behind-the-times Pawlenty is not informed on the issue of Medical Cannabis; or he would at least understand approx. 80-percent of Americans want access to Medical Cannabis. Most Americans believe that locking people up for following their doctors’ recommendations is BARBARIC and has no place in a civilized society. How has the medical and public support completely escaped Pawlenty (what books, magazines and newspapers does Pawlenty read, because he is shockingly ignorant when it comes to the therapeutic value of Medical Cannabis?)?
Years ago, before his recent transformation, Bob Barr single-handedly prevented Washington D.C. from allowing access to Medical Cannabis, with the Barr Amendment to the DC Appropriations Bill.
But a decade later, he is still paying for this cruel and ill-informed obstruction of medicine. Barr will never live down this very ugly mistake that he now deeply regrets. During just about every interview he gives, Barr is asked why he opposed the DC Medical Marijuana bill. Pawlenty may have some backwards and ignorant perceptions of Medical Cannabis, but the sick and seriously ill can’t afford to wait for Pawlenty to “catch up” in the Science department and stop spreading manure.
Why are we giving Gov. Pawlenty a pass on this one, AGAIN? His ignorant rationale for blocking access to medicine for dying and sick people is the exact same contrived B.S. Pawlenty used last year. Make him explain his rationale for opposing Medical Cannabis; don’t let him get away with this not-good-enough “sound bite.” For instance, how will Medical Cannabis make law enforcement more difficult (please have Pawlenty explain why this is so – in precise detail?).
Please call Pawlenty on his lies (it appears the MN media is afraid to call Pawlenty on his ill-informed stance?). Pawlenty’s ignorant and cruel stance needs to be highlighted and publicized across the U.S., TODAY!!
With the Medical Cannabis tide already changing and with most medical professionals pushing for access to medical Cannabis, I hope Pawlenty starts to listen to the health professionals on this issue, because they are the real experts. If it weren’t potentially catastrophic, it would be comical Pawlenty continues to go to the police union for answers to medical questions.
The MN police should not be in charge of medicine and should not be trying to undermine the Will of the People.
Comment posted February 13, 2009 @ 2:33 pm
Here’s a quick glance at an insightful Star-Tribune Poll (as of 2:00 pm Friday – CST) on Medical Cannabis & Minnesota:
Question Polled: Should the Minnesota Legislature make marijuana legal for people with a proven medical need?
Total Votes 3270 (as of 2:00 pm Friday – CST)
A.”Yes, the benefits to ill people outweigh the law enforcement issues.”
2748 or 84% of voters voted “yes” or A.
B. “Only if law enforcement organizations drop their opposition.”
135 or 4.1 % of voters voted for B.
C. “No, it will be made available to people who don’t need it, and will complicate law enforcement efforts to control drug trafficking.”
387 or 11.8 % of voters voted for “No” or C.
As this poll clearly illustrates, Minnesotans want access to Medical Cannabis for their seriously ill and dying patients. However, Pawlenty and a few other misguided lawmakers continue to recklessly disregard the public and medical support and irresponsibly “kick up dirt” to conceal the truth.
Comment posted February 13, 2009 @ 3:08 pm
AMERICAN PUBLIC HEALTH ASSOCIATION ON MEDICAL CANNABIS/MARIJUANA
“[M]arijuana has an extremely wide acute margin of safety for use under medical supervision and cannot cause lethal reactions … [G]reater harm is caused by the legal consequences of its prohibition than possible risks of medicinal use.”
– American Public Health Association, Resolution #9513, “Access to Therapeutic Marijuana/Cannabis,” 1995
The American Public Health Association (APHA) is the oldest and largest organization of public health professionals in the world. The APHA represents more than 50,000 members and has been effectively influencing policies and setting priorities in public health since 1872. I’m guessing the APHA knows a little something about medicine.
Comment posted February 13, 2009 @ 3:25 pm
The opposition to medical marijuana has been reduced to extreme conjecture from the Minnessota Family Council, and conspiracy theory. Should anyone be surprised at this? They are opposing the introduction of a natural medicine that has been shown to effectively help suffering individuals from being available to them. If that isn’t a complete lack of compassion for the sake of a single-minded goal, then I don’t know what is.
What evidence do they have for their conspiracy theory that could stand up in court, and what evidence do they have that shows the introduction of marijuana to be a direct factor in the degradation of the family? Are there not far more pressing factors contributing to said degradation that are not only legal, but encouraged in the American lifestyle? Career mobility, socio-economic status, our need for instant gratification, and the lack of educated understanding of the familial constructs available to producing a functional family unit. Then again, what would I know? I’m just some obscure individual lost in the world of the web.
Comment posted February 14, 2009 @ 10:27 am
The conservative arguments get weaker and more outlandish as time goes by. I look forward to their next salvo of inane and ridiculous statements. Perhaps they’ll try to say that medical marijuana was a plot of the blue aliens in their spaceships to make people docile enough to buy more Cheetos and wear underpants on their heads… just like they did at the RNC private parties.
Comment posted February 14, 2009 @ 4:53 pm
Minnesota should absolutely be the next state to legalize medicinal marijuana! This completely non-addictive plant can be grown from the arctic circle to the antarctic circle, so how can we try to stop it? Nobody has EVER over-dosed on THC–cigarettes and alcohol can KILL you, but are offered to people as soon as they turn 18 or 21…If the country as a whole were to tax marijauana, think about the financial debt that we could eliminate? The canibus plant was used for over 80% of all textiles, ropes, military supplies, etc…just 100 years ago! There are substantial amounts of people that are experiencing major benefits from the use of medicinal marijuana, it just seems immoral to deny someone such relief from pain, nausea, and sleep loss. A police officer’s job is to protect the peace, and keep citizens safe; marijuana does not jepordize this in any way. Our country has much more important things to incarcerate people for than marijuana possession. There are 1000’s of rapists and murderers who don’t have prison cells AVAILABALE to them simply because some other guy got caught with a bag of weed!?! This system has GOT to change.
Comment posted February 16, 2009 @ 12:49 pm
This is a safe medicine and it WORKS! Don’t muddy the waters with pro-legalization talk, -there is another time and place for that. This is about having compassion for your fellow humans and allowing them to use the medicine that they are their DOCTOR (no politicians) have deemed appropriate. Governor Pawlenty’s claim that this will increase crime is ludicrous and lacking factual basis. If you want to ensure that those with debilitating medical conditions will continue to break the law and add to criminal enterprise, what better way to accomplish this than to force people to buy off the street??!! Read the legislation and how restrictive the list of conditions really is. It really saddens me that police unions would rather try to protect drug money budgets and that the Governor is more concerned with his career than helping the sick and dying. I impore people to contact Governor Pawlenty and let him know that he is not gaining any votes by taking a “tough on crime” approach toward the sick and dying. In fact, isn’t this something that would make people second guess him and his motives? In a compassionate society, this wouldn’t even be an issue. The people want this, Governor Pawlenty. Your ambitions for a national spotlight are very transparent. Take your own advice and use this as an opportunity to get back to representing the will of the people. My health, and the health of others, cannot afford to be cast aside again. Do the right thing!
Comment posted March 8, 2009 @ 8:38 pm
Pot is illegal because of racism and capitalism. Read Cannabis: A history. Whenever anything is denied from the public (or pushed on the public) just ask yourself, “who stands to make or lose money?” and that will tell you what the politicians will do, because the people with the money have the access to the government, and what they want is what will happen. That’s the state of our nation today, like it or not.
Comment posted March 11, 2009 @ 2:57 pm
Minnesota has the choice of either spending $20,000 a year to lock up a medical marijuana user or collecting sales tax on the individual’s purchase of this widely used product.
If it’s grow-your-own, consider a $100 per year permit for a dozen plants.
It’s time to put the criminal drug dealers out of business and let ordinary Americans grow a little marijuana in their own back yards.
Comment posted March 13, 2009 @ 8:39 am
My letter to Tom Prichard at the Minnesota Family Council in response to his testimony before the legislature:
“Mr. Prichard,
I am writing you with respect to the MFC policy with regard to medical marijuana. I am a conservative Christian and I have attended church most of my life. I am college educated, have two adult children, and have worked as a chef for many years. I was born with a defect to my left foot that eventually led to a mass forming around my left ankle. This had to be removed surgically, and my ankle had to be fused. As well, I was in an accident that caused injury to my spine which necessitated my spine being fused in two places. The lack of mobility and my career choice has led to constant weight gain because it is very difficult to exercise consistently with so much pain. My doctor at MAPS has had me on various medicines over the years like Morphine, Dilaudid, Fentanyl, and Oxycontin. These are all powerful narcotics, which are extremely addictive, and debilitating. The pills can lead to abuse, so, most recently the doctor has wanted to put me on a Fentanyl transdermal patch, or he said, I could have a pain pump implanted. The patch has been in the news lately because some of them have failed catastrophically and led to the death of the patient using them. The pain pump is implanted surgically and delivers the narcotic directly into the spinal column and requires a port to inject the medicine into. Neither of these options is viable for me. I want off the narcotics, but every time that I try to wean myself off of them, the pain comes back worse than ever, and I experience cold sweats, nausea, vomiting, shaking, insomnia, and hallucinations: all to the extreme. Legislation that would allow me to medicate myself by smoking a small amount of Marijuana is before the Minnesota State legislature and you constantly lobby against it. I take exception with your characterization of the bill that it would allow anyone over 18 years of age to grow “pot.” You are sensationalizing the issue, and acting as though this will give everyone access to Marijuana. That is absurd! I do not support legalization of Marijuana for the broader public, but I ask myself “why you are so adamant about denying me the ability to legally, safely, and cheaply procure, and use medical Marijuana?” Let’s face it, if you want to buy “pot” it isn’t that difficult, and I see addicts constantly manipulating doctors at the pain clinic. They don’t even look like the rest of the patients, and are easy to spot, and that is for “legal“medication. My doctor has said that he would support my use of Marijuana as soon as the state legalizes its use medically, but my own conservative, Christian brethren are lobbying against it. I have prayed about this so much, and the only thing preventing me from using Marijuana is that it is illegal to do so under the current law, and the Bible says to obey the law of the land. This is pure insanity! I pray that the Minnesota Family Council will reconsider their stand on this issue, and relent to support it as a compassionate legal alternative to powerful narcotics, and surgical implantation of medical devices, to use by those with terminal illness, and chronic intractable pain among others. Until you can do that, I ask that you please remove me from your mailing list, and email list. Thank you for listening, and for your prayerful consideration of this matter. I have included all of my contact information so that you know I am a real person and not a troll, and I welcome any reasonable dialogue in regards to this matter. In Christ, David Copenhaver”
Comment posted May 1, 2009 @ 5:02 pm
Gov Pawlenty needs to understand that the plant is what God gave us to use.
Synthetic drugs are not always the answer and can cause more harm then good.
As far as teenage boys growing pot ( that made me chuckle ) , what about the teenage boys stealing drugs out of their parents medicine cabinets that are far more dangerous then pot ?
My sister in-law is suffering from cancer and cannot eat unless she takes an addicting benzodiazepine which she’ll need to take every day in order to acquire much needed nutrition.
Benzodiazepine’s are one the most difficult drugs to quit much more so then heroin or crack!
She isn’t getting much relief from the benzo poison and is wasting away.
My sister passed away from cancer and was struggling for nutrition as Marinol didn’t work.
She needed MANY benzo’s daily as after awhile one builds up tolerance thus everything becomes worse. If she survived she would had been in hell trying to get off the poison.
I miss her so very much as she was my only sister and needn’t suffer as much as she did.
I feel the same about my sister in-law .
I myself have chronic insomnia where I cannot fall asleep AT ALL 24/7 w/out a bloody synthetic benzo or hypnotic. I’ve been juggling these horrid drugs and suffering w/the side effects which are making my life more miserable.
Mr.Pawlenty PLEASE WAKE UP !
Must we wait for YOU or someone YOU love to go through this hell ?
http://www.benzo.org.uk/
Comment posted May 19, 2009 @ 9:25 am
I have Cronic Pain Mental health problems & also an eating disorder & 4 me Taking a couple puffs off a joint helps me 2 enjoy a fews hours of NO PAIN!!! There’s times I just want 2 make the pain stop 4ever by ending my LIFE. However, I turn 2 Marijuana when I must eat due 2 almost passing out from lack of food. I’M PLEADING 4 THOSE WHO CAN MAKE THIS MARIJUANA LEGAL 4 THOSE OF US WHO NEED IT!!!!!!!!
PLEASE HELP!!!
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL
Leave a comment