Norm Coleman was compared — unfavorably, as I read it — to Richard Nixon in Sunday’s New York Times Magazine. Reporter Matt Bai writes that when Nixon foresaw a trouncing in 1960 he “exited quickly to begin plotting his return to office.” Not so with Coleman, whose concession holdout in the Minnesota Senate race now has spanned four meteorological seasons. But Media Matters’ Eric Boehlert takes issue with how favorable Bai’s take on Coleman’s delay is.
One section of Bai’s piece that Boehlert cites [emphasis his]:
Even before he ran for re-election to the Senate, Norm Coleman saw more than his share of ignominious elections. First he lost the Minnesota governorship to a former pro wrestler who called himself the Body. Then he just barely managed to wrest a Senate seat from an opponent, Paul Wellstone, who had recently perished in a plane crash. So can you really blame Coleman for having spent the last eight months furiously trying not to have to concede defeat to Al Franken – a man who once acted alongside a gorilla on the set of “Trading Places”?
“[D]oes anybody think that if Coleman had lost to a Democratic candidate who was an attorney or an investment banker than Coleman wouldn’t have also pursued the same, losing delay strategy?” Boehlert asks. “Of course, not. But the press loves to point out how Franken’s just a comedian. Why? Because the Beltway press doesn’t take Franken seriously, which is one reason pundits and reporters have played dumb about Coleman’s extraordinary and unprecedented sore loser routine in 2009.”
What’s worse, writes Boehlert, is that the Times frames Coleman’s delay not as being a “sore loser” (a phrase we often heard applied to that other Al — Gore — in 2000) but as “the lengths to which losing candidates will now routinely go” (emphasis mine).
“Coleman’s not part of any larger cultural trend where politicians can no longer concede defeat,” Boehlert concludes. “Hundreds (thousands?) of them do it every election cycle in cities and states across the country. Coleman represents the radical exception, but the ’liberal media’ are too timid to call him out on it.”














6 Comments »
Comment posted June 22, 2009 @ 1:20 pm
I can read the news too… I don’t get paid to post in the articles I read, like you do… but yes I have read both these articles. Pity… I thought I was going to get to read another one but I guess simply pasting a few articles together is enough to pay your rent.
Comment posted June 22, 2009 @ 1:36 pm
First time reading a blog, Troy?
Comment posted June 22, 2009 @ 1:44 pm
First time reading such a high profile one with absolutely no synthesis of the quoted material.
Comment posted June 22, 2009 @ 2:35 pm
It’s interesting to me that the article slams Franken for …. working in comedy, as though there is something wrong with that.
Franken is more knowledgeable about public policy than people give him credit for. I suspect that he knows much more about it than the vast majority of journalists, especially those lightweights on CNN and Fox News.
I look forward to Mr. Franken being my 2nd Senator from Minnesota, joining Senator Klobuchar as soon as the Mn Supreme Court wraps up it’s work on the Coleman Election Contest Court Decision appeal.
Comment posted June 22, 2009 @ 2:54 pm
The beltway press is looking shabbier and shabbier as time drags on! Franken is a comedian, which means he is constantly searching the news for items of that demonstrate irony, contradiction, or just plain stupidity. He sees the world with skepticism and is trained to apply critical thinking.to recognize the absurdities of life. He is quick, glib, and articulate, all of the qualities we seek in our politicians. Coleman is a second-rater, a dull yes man to our dumbest, least interested, and possibly laziest president, George W. Bush.
If the press doesn’t see this, we are being ill-served by those elevated by the newspapers and networks to their level of reportage or punditry.
To me it’s Franken, hands-down. Let’s get this shabby charade over and let the man take his rightful seat.
Comment posted June 24, 2009 @ 6:07 am
Funny how the Beltway press went so easy on Ronald Reagan (who acted alongside a gorilla named “Bonzo”). Or renowned airhead Sonny Bono (former Congressman from California), who died from colliding with a tree while skiing and who was an ardent fan of Newt Gingrich.
Franken has remained on the sidelines during the past six months for the most part, while Coleman has whined and pouted. Coleman and his lawyers have ranted about the Minnesota Canvassing Board and the Minnesota judicial system, portraying the state he once represented in Congress as “podunk” in order to serve their needs.
Who does the “press” take seriously? Imbeciles like Sarah Palin and Bobby Jindal…a sad commentary on the state of journalism on the national level.
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL
Leave a comment