DFL convention: Franken v. Nelson-Pallmeyer

There were no surprise nominations from the convention floor this morning. Most notably, the name Mike Ciresi was not uttered by any delegates. That means the endorsement battle will come down to Al Franken and Jack Nelson-Pallmeyer (unless Mr. No Endorsement shows up).

Among the primary gripes about Al Franken’s candidacy in the long lead up to the DFL convention has been that he’s not particularly impressive on the stump. For someone who’s spent his life in the entertainmbent business he can be surprisingly stiff and rambling.

“When it comes to debates he is very, very poor,” says delegate Barb Olsen, for example, who started out a Franken supporter, but was won over by Nelson-Pallmeyer at an early debate. “That’s going to be needed in the general election agiainst Norm Coleman.”

Franken had a final opportunity to change that perception in an hour-long Q & A session before balloting begins for the DFL endorsement. Given that his support is undoubtedly a bit soft following weeks of negative media coverage, it was also a potentially treacherous event.

Unfortunately for Franken, Nelson-Pallmeyer is no stodgy academic. He’s a dynamic speaker who throws out plenty of red meat for the DFL faithful.

The freewheeling debate touched on Iraq, immigration, health care, and economic issues. Franken gave a particularly strong answer when asked why he’s a Democrat. He mentioned that his father was a staunch Republican until the civil rights movement. But after witnessing protesters being assaulted by firehoses in Alabama his perspective changed. “My dad said that is wrong,” Franken recalls. “No jew can be for that.”

Nelson-Pallmeyer used the question to criticize the Democratic party for its feeble conduct in the run-up to the Iraq war. “If Democrats had stood up to the politics of fear we would not be in Iraq today,” he stated.

The college professor also sought to differentiate himself from Franken on health-care issues, arguing that we need a national, single-payer health care plan. “It’s not enough to say you are for universal health care,” he said. “I love my mom and apple pie too, but how do we get there?”

Franken countered by saying he wants to get to universal health care as quickly as possible, no matter what the system. “You don’t have to be sick to know that our healthcare system is broken,” he stated.

Immediately after the debate, the Franken campaign announced a minor boon for his candidacy: the endorsement of the DFL Feminist Caucus. “Al very strongly demonstrated an understanding of our issues and we know he’ll represent us in Washington,” said caucus member Jackie Stevenson in a statement. Given recent criticism from female DFL legislators about some of Franken’s past writings, this could prove influential with some delegates.