Begich begs, so Franken adds Alaska, Hawaii to his freehand map of the USA

By Chris Steller
Tuesday, August 11, 2009 at 11:39 am

franken mapU.S. Sen. Al Franken has acceded to a formal request from Sen. Mark Begich (D-Alaska) that the Minnesota senator add Alaska and Hawaii when he draws freehand maps of the United States as a parlor trick. Franken, whose 2007 campaign-trail performance of the stunt is on YouTube (see it after the jump), promised Begich that “henceforth, my marvelous hand-drawn map of the United States will include the forty-ninth and fiftieth states, which are either Hawaii and Alaska or Alaska and Hawaii.”

Politico has an exhaustive, heavily linked post documenting all the back-and-forth between Begich and Franken, with pdfs of both men’s letters (Begich cited his familial-political roots on Minnesota’s Iron Range), including a dot-to-dot puzzle that Begich sent along as a guide:

alaska follow the dots

Franken traces the source of his talent to another kind of puzzle, a jigsaw puzzle from his youth:

First of all, let me be clear that I am very well aware that Alaska and Hawaii are states. It’s just that when I was a child, my parents gave me a wood puzzle-map of the United States, which then included only the forty-eight contiguous states.

It wasn’t until years later, sometime in the early to middle sixties, I believe, that Hawaii and Alaska became full-fledged members of the union. Please know that I have assigned a staffer to get me the hard data on this.

Anyway, the point is, I learned only the forty-eight states on the wooden puzzle given to me by my hard-working parents. To include Alaska and Hawaii, while certainly common-sensical, would, I am afraid, dishonor the memory of both my mom and dad.

However, since you are a colleague that is a sacrifice I’m only too happy to make.

alfrankenstates

Below is the YouTube of Franken drawing the (lower 48) states in three-and-a-half minutes, at a April 28, 2007, DFL fundraiser in Rochester, just two months into what became a two-and-a-half year struggle to reach the U.S. Senate. In the course of drawing the map, Franken keeps up a running commentary:

You know why Minnesota is so windy? The Dakotas blow and Wisconsin sucks. … Here’s where my wife’s from: Maine. No, it’s not the northernmost state. Don’t be ridiculous. We [Minnesota] were until– By the way, I will not draw Alaska and Hawaii. I refuse to. … I don’t know about you but I’m incredibly impressed. … Watch it speed up as we go out West where the states have too many electoral votes for [their] population.

On a personal note (and maybe I should send an actual personal note as Begich did), I’d like to ask Franken to include a dot for Mount Steller, in the Aleutian Islands — from which, as Begich says of Little Diomede Island, you can see Russia.

mount steller map

Comments

9 Comments

Eric Ferguson
Comment posted August 11, 2009 @ 3:02 pm

“It wasn’t until years later, sometime in the early to middle sixties, I believe, that Hawaii and Alaska became full-fledged members of the union. Please know that I have assigned a staffer to get me the hard data on this.”

Please tell me there aren’t people out there who think Franken really doesn’t know. The bit about a staffer researching it should be a giveaway that he’s kidding.

Right after I wrote that last sentence, I followed the link to Politico and yes, at least one commenter thought they needed to correct him.


Typical Wingnut
Comment posted August 11, 2009 @ 4:25 pm

“It wasn’t until years later, sometime in the early to middle sixties, I believe, that Hawaii and Alaska became full-fledged members of the union. Please know that I have assigned a staffer to get me the hard data on this.”

Good God! This means Obama isn’t a citizen! Even Al Franken admits it!


mobedda
Comment posted August 11, 2009 @ 5:57 pm

@ Eric F.: Yeah, can’t fix dumb. Having an operational sense of humor is crucial to not failing life.


CestWhat
Comment posted August 11, 2009 @ 8:04 pm

There are two funny poll results. In Utah, the most solidly Republican state in the Union but also the most white, 9% of self-identified Republican didn’t believe or had doubts Barack Obama was born in the United States.

While in North Carolina, which Barack Obama won about also have much larger non-White population, 9% of Republicans didn’t believe or had doubts that Hawaii is part of the United States.

I’m not sure what to do with that, but it’s odd, right?


D Koski
Comment posted August 12, 2009 @ 12:49 am

Great article. I sure am proud and happy to have Franken as my Senator.
Over time even the most hardened Franken hater will warm up to him. Maybe.


Jan Flora
Comment posted August 12, 2009 @ 3:25 am

Senator Al Franken (gawd, it feels good to write that) is a wonderful asset to the US Senate. I’m sure glad he prevailed. I’m proud of you Minnesotans for having the good sense to elect such fine senators. And I’m really happy that my Junior Senator, Mark Begich, browbeat Sen. Franken into including the 49th state, Alaska, (January 3, 1959) and the 50th state, Hawaii, (August 21, 1959) into his totally cool map of the United States.

Could you guys do everyone a favor and run Michelle Bachmann off? She’s almost as looney as our Bitter Quitter Governor and just as dangerous. — Kudos from Homer, Alaska


Ed Bradly
Comment posted August 12, 2009 @ 9:06 am

The “Bitter Quitter Governor”. I may borrow that if you don’t mind.


Jiggle
Comment posted August 12, 2009 @ 11:29 am

Not to nitpick a brilliant map (I can barely draw my own home state), alas, Arkansas and Kentucky do not share a border.


Al Franken Adds Hawaii and Alaska to his GeoTrick : Geo Lounge – All things geography
Pingback posted August 12, 2009 @ 2:34 pm

[...] Minnesota Independent reports on correspondence between Senators Al Franken and Mark Begich (D-Alaska).  Begich pleaded with Franken to added Alaska and Hawaii to his freehand drawing of the [...]


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.