Rep. Michele Bachmann called for the defunding of Planned Parenthood on Wednesday. In a "special order" floor speech organized by Bachmann and Chris Smith, R-N.J., Bachmann called for an end to any federal money for the network of reproductive health care clinics because Planned Parenthood offers abortion services.
"If you’ve got 882 clinics, you have $1 billion a year in annual revenue, and $330 million of that comes from taxpayer funding, I think that shows pretty clearly they are big business. They are the Wal-Mart of big abortion. They’re the big box retailer," Bachmann told fellow members of the House. "It is time to end their tax-exempt status. It’s a fraud. And it’s time to stop the public financing of Planned Parenthood. It’s the right thing to do."
Tim Stanley, executive director of Planned Parenthood Minnesota, North Dakota, South Dakota (PPMNS) Action Fund, took issue with Bachmann’s characterization. "Planned Parenthood does more in one day to prevent unintended pregnancy and the need for abortion than politicians like Michele Bachmann do in a lifetime,” said Stanley.
Indeed, Planned Parenthood offers a range of services in addition to abortion services, including those that prevent the need for abortion: access to birth control, emergency contraception, pregnancy options counseling, sexuality education, and vasectomies and tubal ligations. Those services are in addition to a range of other reproductive health services such as screening for breast, cervical and testicular cancers; pregnancy testing; testing and treatment for sexually transmitted diseases; and menopause treatments.
“In spite of what Michelle Bachmann says, Planned Parenthood served nearly 65,000 people last year," said Stanley. "What this means is that more Minnesotans than ever are in need of health care services, and PPMNS is the safety net health care provider they turn to for the care they need. Nearly 76 percent of PPMNS patients are very low-income and likely to qualify for public insurance programs."
Those services are offered to men and women who might not otherwise have access to or be able to afford birth control and other reproductive health services.
Planned Parenthood’s expansion into more affluent areas is what triggered Bachmann’s heightened voice in the abortion debate.
The Wall Street Journal reported last month that Planned Parenthood has rebranded its operation and had opened express centers in several affluent Minneapolis-St. Paul suburbs.
"Well, let me tell you, they’ve made a decision, Planned Parenthood, that they are going to go after the affluent. How do I know that? It’s happening in my district, and it was detailed in this article," said Bachmann. "It said three express centers [opening] in wealthy Minnesota suburbs and shopping centers and malls, places where women are already doing their grocery shopping, picking up their Starbucks, living their daily lives."
Bachmann continued, "Do we understand what this is? This is to promote women, to promote that woman intentionally take the lives of their unborn children," she said. "We are asking God-fearing Americans to subsidize this brutal and bloody procedure on a regular business in upscale shopping malls all across the United States."
Despite Bachmann’s assertion, the Wall Street Journal makes clear that abortion services are not being offered in "upscale shopping malls." The article says that the mall sites in Minnesota offer "services limited to birth-control counseling and tests for pregnancy or sexually transmitted infections. Most patients are in and out in less than half an hour."













18 Comments »
Comment posted August 5, 2008 @ 5:37 am
juliesandburg
Posted jul 14 2008 10:54am with +1 vote
Is this woman “goddamn” insane?
Real nice comment there Julie. See you in church. I’m personally sick and tired of my money going towards this. Ever hear of adoption? How about birth control minus the abortion/murder part? It makes me sick to my stomach that people can so arbitrarily end a life. And talk to some women who have had abortions when they are young as I have. Most carry the guilt the rest of their lives, so abortion in reality harms more than the fetus, but the women and even the potential father if he even knew about it…
Comment posted August 1, 2008 @ 4:24 am
Face it, folks. Planned Parenthood does not deserve your support or mine. As a mother and grandmother, I am angry at having my tax money suport an organization that hosts a pornographic website for teenagers. I am aghast at the fact that P P staff members have frequently concealed exploitation of minor girls by older men. Yes, they quietly abort them and remain mum to protect the exploiters. I am not fooled by their recent ploy of touting the “other services” they provide to obscure the fact that they are by far the largest provider of abortions in the country. With due respect to Mr. Birkey, I suggest he do a little research into the relationship between contraception and abortion. He would find that providing access to contraception increases the abortion rate instead of reducing the need for it as he ascerts. And what of pregnancy option counselling? Well he would find a glaring imbalance between the number of womem aborted and the number directed to keep their babies. Just look up the figures! Whatever one’s opinion of Ms Bachmann, it should not be allowed to obscure the truth about Planned Parenthood.
Comment posted July 24, 2008 @ 10:26 am
The reality of this woman demonstrates why the rest of America looks askance at Minnesota. She is obviously a bubble or two off plumb, yet she resides in the Minnesota State House. The folks who elected her may have been fooled, but if the people in her district were wise, they’d stop with the “Minnesota Nice,” which is the most annoying passive-aggressive behavior, and ship her back to whatever rock she crawled up from under
Comment posted July 14, 2008 @ 4:37 pm
“If you’ve got 882 clinics, you have $1 billion a year in annual revenue, and $330 million of that comes from taxpayer funding”
Kind of sounds like several of our nation’s larger churches. Big main church, lots of branches throughout the country, taxpayer funding (indirectly through being tax exempt).
Wonder if she would be in favor of shutting those down too?
I like the ‘put your money’ idea of dbower. I’m going straight from here to donate to Tinklenberg’s site.
Comment posted July 14, 2008 @ 12:40 pm
I completely agree with Ericf. I just donated $25. The old “put your money where your mouth is” slogan goes well here. I have despised this woman for two years now. I am ashamed that she is from my state. Let’s fund the opposition. C’mon fellow sane readers!!!
Comment posted July 14, 2008 @ 12:11 pm
“Well, let me tell you, they’ve made a decision, Planned Parenthood, that they are going to go after the affluent. How do I know that? It’s happening in my district, and it was detailed in this article,” said Bachmann.
I think it is interesting that she says her district is affluent. Most of her district (and mine) consists of middle class, working class, and the working poor.
I would also like to hear what Elwyn Tinklenberg has to say in response to this attack on Planned Parenthood.
Comment posted July 14, 2008 @ 11:48 am
Be sane, and help Elwyn Tinklenberg defeat this embarrassment. http://www.actblue.com/contribute/entity/18660
Comment posted July 14, 2008 @ 11:46 am
“Well, let me tell you, they’ve made a decision, Planned Parenthood, that they are going to go after the affluent. How do I know that? It’s happening in my district, and it was detailed in this article,”
that’s an interesting statement….
Comment posted July 14, 2008 @ 10:54 am
Is this woman goddamn insane?
Comment posted July 14, 2008 @ 5:54 am
Is this woman goddamn insane?
Comment posted July 14, 2008 @ 6:46 am
“Well, let me tell you, they've made a decision, Planned Parenthood, that they are going to go after the affluent. How do I know that? It's happening in my district, and it was detailed in this article,”
that's an interesting statement….
Comment posted July 14, 2008 @ 6:48 am
Be sane, and help Elwyn Tinklenberg defeat this embarrassment. http://www.actblue.com/contribute/entity/18660
Comment posted July 14, 2008 @ 7:11 am
“Well, let me tell you, they've made a decision, Planned Parenthood, that they are going to go after the affluent. How do I know that? It's happening in my district, and it was detailed in this article,” said Bachmann.
I think it is interesting that she says her district is affluent. Most of her district (and mine) consists of middle class, working class, and the working poor.
I would also like to hear what Elwyn Tinklenberg has to say in response to this attack on Planned Parenthood.
Comment posted July 14, 2008 @ 7:40 am
I completely agree with Ericf. I just donated $25. The old “put your money where your mouth is” slogan goes well here. I have despised this woman for two years now. I am ashamed that she is from my state. Let's fund the opposition. C'mon fellow sane readers!!!
Comment posted July 14, 2008 @ 11:37 am
“If you've got 882 clinics, you have $1 billion a year in annual revenue, and $330 million of that comes from taxpayer funding”
Kind of sounds like several of our nation's larger churches. Big main church, lots of branches throughout the country, taxpayer funding (indirectly through being tax exempt).
Wonder if she would be in favor of shutting those down too?
I like the 'put your money' idea of dbower. I'm going straight from here to donate to Tinklenberg's site.
Comment posted July 24, 2008 @ 5:26 am
The reality of this woman demonstrates why the rest of America looks askance at Minnesota. She is obviously a bubble or two off plumb, yet she resides in the Minnesota State House. The folks who elected her may have been fooled, but if the people in her district were wise, they'd stop with the “Minnesota Nice,” which is the most annoying passive-aggressive behavior, and ship her back to whatever rock she crawled up from under
Comment posted July 31, 2008 @ 11:24 pm
Face it, folks. Planned Parenthood does not deserve your support or mine. As a mother and grandmother, I am angry at having my tax money suport an organization that hosts a pornographic website for teenagers. I am aghast at the fact that P P staff members have frequently concealed exploitation of minor girls by older men. Yes, they quietly abort them and remain mum to protect the exploiters. I am not fooled by their recent ploy of touting the “other services” they provide to obscure the fact that they are by far the largest provider of abortions in the country. With due respect to Mr. Birkey, I suggest he do a little research into the relationship between contraception and abortion. He would find that providing access to contraception increases the abortion rate instead of reducing the need for it as he ascerts. And what of pregnancy option counselling? Well he would find a glaring imbalance between the number of womem aborted and the number directed to keep their babies. Just look up the figures! Whatever one's opinion of Ms Bachmann, it should not be allowed to obscure the truth about Planned Parenthood.
Comment posted August 5, 2008 @ 12:37 am
juliesandburg
Posted jul 14 2008 10:54am with +1 vote
Is this woman “goddamn” insane?
Real nice comment there Julie. See you in church. I'm personally sick and tired of my money going towards this. Ever hear of adoption? How about birth control minus the abortion/murder part? It makes me sick to my stomach that people can so arbitrarily end a life. And talk to some women who have had abortions when they are young as I have. Most carry the guilt the rest of their lives, so abortion in reality harms more than the fetus, but the women and even the potential father if he even knew about it…
RSS feed for comments on this post.
Leave a comment