When Maplewood city council candidate Jim Llanas told the Minnesota Independent this summer, “Brace yourself. It’s just going to get ugly,” he wasn’t far off the mark. An anonymous flier being distributed about Llanas, who would be both the first openly gay and the first Hispanic city council member in the city’s history, is being described as racist and homophobic by a progressive group and a city council member.
“Llanas, a non-native of Maplewood, apparently spends much of his time in Minneapolis supporting gay politicians,” the flier reads. “How does this qualify him to run for Maplewood city council?”
It then says that Llanas has gone by several names, including his middle name “Moreno,” and that he has been involved in the LGBT community.
The fliers have been distributed in Maplewood neighborhoods, and in numerous instances they’ve been taped on doors along with an attached campaign brochure — in many cases affixed with the same blue tape — promoting conservative council candidate Dave Hafner and write-in candidates DelRay Rokke (council) and Ken Smart (mayor).
Current city council member John Nephew first spotted the fliers and posted them on his blog. “For whatever it’s worth, I don’t think those three were born in Maplewood either, but you know that’s not really what the flyer is getting at with the term ‘non-native.’”
There’s no proof that any of those candidates were responsible for the flier, and Llanas points to comments on a blog where Smart said he doesn’t have any knowledge of the flier.
The flier also attacks Llanas’ work in human rights. “Llanas wants to establish a Human Rights commission on the city council. The question is which humans? When was the last time a human rights commission did anything for you???”
Llanas condemned the flier on his campaign website:
Using a strategy right from the Karl Rove playbook, supporters of my opponents are using fear and hate to get votes. They blanket neighborhoods in the dark of night, afraid to show their faces. These slimey tactics make incorrect assumptions about Maplewood residents. They assume Maplewood residents are uninformed, comfortable with people who divide our community and tolerant of bigots. The fact is residents are deeply engaged with the affairs of our city and are fed up with this type of political nonsense!
Progressive Majority, a “political action committee committed to progressive candidates and issues,” also condemned the fliers and rushed to support Llanas in an email on Wednesday.
Jim has been called “a non-native of Maplewood” and been attacked for “supporting gay politicians.” The residents of Maplewood are facing a new low in the politics of bigotry and hatred …
The attacks, meant only to stoke racism and homophobia among voters, remind us of the Jim Crow days in the American South. While we are confident that the residents of Maplewood will reject the politics of bigotry, we also know that Jim needs help to get his message out.
Click here for a PDF version of the flier.











27 Comments »
Pingback posted October 21, 2009 @ 2:41 pm
[...] MinnIndependent reports: When Maplewood city council candidate Jim Llanas told the Minnesota Independent this summer, “Brace yourself. It’s just going to get ugly,” he wasn’t far off the mark. An anonymous flier being distributed about Llanas, who would be both the first openly gay and the first Hispanic city council member in the city’s history, is being described as racist and homophobic by a progressive group and a city council member. [...]
Comment posted October 21, 2009 @ 3:12 pm
“Llanas wants to establish a Human Rights commission on the city council. The question is which humans? When was the last time a human rights commission did anything for you???”
Comment posted October 21, 2009 @ 4:04 pm
If the bulk of this candidate’s public record consists of efforts in Minneapolis on behalf of the gay rights crowd, that is something voters of Maplewood should know about.
Given the current financial meltdown and high unemployment, making the creation of a “human rights” commission his priority leads a reasonable person to conclude that moving the gay rights agenda forward is job #1 for Llanas.
That too, is something that the voters are entitled to consider.
None of the excerpts you’ve posted are defamatory, they are informative and thought provoking. But perhaps there is something more inflammatory that you’ve neglected to quote.
Why not post the entire pamphlet and let your readers decide?
Comment posted October 21, 2009 @ 6:42 pm
Thinking man, Jim has been following Maplewood politics for several years. He is interested in organized trash hauling, balancing taxes and services, and the parks, for starters. Jim has also interviewed many residents, and posted the interviews.
We need a politician who can remain polite yet focused when dealing with dissent among residents. I’m tired of politicians who waffle, pass the buck, make unsubstantiated charges, etc.
He has my vote.
Comment posted October 21, 2009 @ 10:07 pm
Mine too. I hadn’t altogether made up my mind, but this sort of “campaigning” automatically turns me against whatever the anonymous cowards are trying to promote. Go, Jim!
Comment posted October 21, 2009 @ 10:27 pm
We need more good, decent, honest representatives like Jim.
More Jims, fewer anonymous cowards.
Comment posted October 21, 2009 @ 10:29 pm
Any publicity is good publicity. I would just say thanks, for supporting me.
Comment posted October 22, 2009 @ 6:34 am
Llanas’ website indicates some of his main reasons for running are to create a Proud Maplewood and that he is tired of seeing our city portrayed in a “negative light”. I doubt he imagined he would be the target. It takes courage to stand up and do what is right and that is why he will get my vote. These extremist and nut-balls exist every where and do not speak for all of Maplewood. I may not agree with everything he stands for but he seems informed, reasonable and sane compared to the other three candidates and that is good enough for me!
Comment posted October 22, 2009 @ 7:15 am
I had never heard of James Llanas before this flyer. I did my research and I am impressed enough that I will cast my vote for him Nov 3. I agree with “Lazercat”, good publicity for Jim and FAIL for the crazy folk!
Comment posted October 22, 2009 @ 9:35 am
It would have been helpful if Andy Birkey had included a link to the posted brochure on the John Nephew site so we could see the entire brochure and the excerpted comments in context. I doubt that Birkey has miscatagorized the content or intent of the brochure, but as long as he mentioned that it was posted online, he should have included a link so that readers could mnake up their own minds. Excerpting without context is in itself a very questionable practice, and in this case becomes suspicious itself when providing the full context would have been so easy.
Comment posted October 22, 2009 @ 10:16 am
Gary,
He did: See the last line of the piece, or download the flier here.
Comment posted October 22, 2009 @ 11:20 am
It is heartening to see so many rational folks saying that this type of negative behavior turns them off; actually going to Llanas’ web site and reading his info (hey Dano and “thinking man”, something you should try!).
Personally I think some diversity in Maplewood including the Council is long overdue!
Comment posted October 22, 2009 @ 11:22 am
so what is wrong with the flier? this article seems like a lame attempt at PC bullying – hardly a shock given the source
Pingback posted October 22, 2009 @ 3:06 pm
[...] Minnesota Independent reports that a flier being distributed against openly gay Maplewood city council candidate Jim LLanas [...]
Comment posted October 22, 2009 @ 4:08 pm
Typical Republi-thug tactics. Why don’t any DFLers ever play the game the way the Republi-thugs do? If they would, maybe we would already have a Democrat Governor.
Comment posted October 23, 2009 @ 3:17 pm
@T-Paw Is A Jerk
“Why don’t any DFLers ever play the game the way the Republi-thugs do?”
Moral objections aside, maybe because they don’t work? Have you seen the state of conservatism and the Republican Party lately?
Comment posted October 23, 2009 @ 3:44 pm
“Rational man”: If you’d like to comment again, please follow our comment policies. I’ve deleted your last comment, which violated the final rule: http://minnesotaindependent.com/policies
Comment posted October 24, 2009 @ 11:02 pm
Neither Dave Hafner (nor Ken Smart or DelRay Rocky) are racist, sexist, or homophobic. I personally don’t care if James Llanis is gay. I lived in Portland, Oregon for two years. I was born and raised in the Twin cities. And I played baseball in Florida long enough. These are three of the top four hotbeds for the gay lifestyle in the United States. I know many gay people and some of them are my friends.. Not because they are (or are not) gay. I also work with and socialize with gay individuals If we are going to do our jobs (assuming we have one) and if we truly believe in freedom and human rights and treating people justly and respectfully, then these are things we all should do. Some of the friends and aquaintences of whom I speak represent some of the kindest and gentlest people that I know. One is no longer with us and I miss him dearly. He was a former student teacher of mine.
I don’t care if people are white, black, brown, yellow, red, or polka dot green. If there were people that were polka dot green you can bet some of them would be my friends. I don’t know anyone that is actually white, black, red or yellow. I do know many that are “brown” and some that I guess you could call some shade of “yellow.” I also consider some of them to be my friends.
If one is truly non-racist, then you will not find yourself continually referring to the color of a person’s skin. Why does James Llanas continually do this? Council member John Nephew calls the Smart team “lily-white and not all gay.” (Look it up on his web site before he deletes it, as he has done so many times before). Johnny Nephew has his colors mixed up, and needs to break out his box of crayola crayons to determine the difference. They should be next to the rest of his toys.
I have lived right next to two Hmong families and still do. For 17 years on the East side of St. Paul and for the last five years in our city, Maplewood. Sao and Shoua and their children are the nicest, quietest, most respectful people I know. And some of the best neighbors I’ve had the pleasure of living next to. They can’t afford the house payments and have a for-sale sign in the front yard. I will miss them and none better will take their place. Gau, Za, and their children Sher, Ka, Chu, Cheng, Mary, and Pauline are as nice a family as you will ever meet. Gau is the best welder I’ve seen (and I know a few) and Sher is so honest he returned the 35 cents that fell out of my pocket.
Rigoberto Huerta lived next door to my parents for years. We affectionately call him Rigo.. He now lives with his family in my parents former house of 55 years and the house I grew up in. My parents moved to Maplewood. Rigo and his family are Hispanic. They also are some of the nicest, kindest, generous people we know. The Hispanic community impresses me as being a group of dedicated, hardworking, and respectful people. And they are predominantly Christian. We like that.
It is time to put a rest to the hype, name-calling, false accusations, character assassination and rotten politics that are destroying our city and nation. It is time to free ourselves from the slanted and dishonest viewpoints of the media and the press. And it is time to vote for the only three candidates who are running without an agenda. We are sending you the row boat, the canoe, and the helicopter. Take your pick and jump in. They won’t be coming by again. This is the place, and this is the time. Write (right)-in SMART for mayor, ROCKY for council. No need for first or middle names. Fill in their ovals with the black marker, and fill in Dave Hafner’s oval as well. My name is on the ballot. Vote for SMART team.
Comment posted October 24, 2009 @ 11:07 pm
Lyn Crosby (as well as all other citizens) should go to the links underneath James Llanas’ web site. Two thru six to be exact. Then you will discover the real James Llanas. I do not care if James Llanas is gay. I have read the anonymous campaign literature that was distributed. I see no racist or homophobic intent in it. I do see a number of facts, many of which come from Llanas’ website and the website of the Victory Fund (which is the fourth link down on Google). There are a few opinions that appear to be reasonable conclusions to me. Llanas is not around much(one council meeting?)and has not exhibited any interest in the people of Maplewood at large (although his words and speeches claim otherwise) and appears to have a very obvious personal and political agenda. Suspicion is warranted.
As for “anonymous” campaign literature, independents are allowed to distribute such without putting disclaimers on the bottom. After seeing how I have been getting ripped to shreds (for merely running for the Maplewood council) I would not blame anyone for resisting the urge to remain so. Cowards? These people obviously are quite the opposite.
Comment posted October 25, 2009 @ 12:05 am
Thanks for the comments, Dave. Per our comment policy, I’ve deleted your previous comments that were posted under multiple other names. If you’d like to keep commenting, please stick with this one.
Our comment policy:
http://minnesotaindependent.com/policies
Comment posted October 25, 2009 @ 3:42 pm
Hello,
I found the anonymous literature to be racist and homophobic – how would anyone NOT see it as this? I was appalled. What is happening to Maplewood? I also checked out Mr. Llanas’ website, and specifically his Issues. I need to say that I agree with his issues. Sometimes difficult decisions need to be made in cities’, states, and in the country. Taxes is one of those difficult decisions. The citizens of Maplewood needs to have their basic needs in Maplewood – police, fire, snow removal, etc. And I agree about the Human Rights Commission.
OK, now for a little self-disclosure here – I lived in Maplewood for 38 years. Twenty years ago, I moved to North St. Paul. I love Maplewood and have many family and friends who live there, and I attend church in Maplewood, and do much shopping in Maplewood. It disturbs me regarding the negative atmosphere at the Maplewood City Council meetings. What is happening to Maplewood? Where is the “working-together” atmosphere? I think a change is needed in Maplewood’s mayor, and a fresh face in the council. I am not saying who to vote for, that is for the citizens of Maplewood to decide. I hope that all of the citizens of Maplewood vote without looking at someone’s sexual orientation, race, where they came from, etc. I hope that Maplewood citizens vote as I know they can, looking for the qualities of the candidates. I will be watching Election Night with much anticipation and hope.
Thank you.
P.S. I also love North St. Paul, and I am also going to advocate for a Human Rights Commission in my city of North St. Paul. I believe this is needed in all cities. Again, thank you.
Jean
Comment posted October 25, 2009 @ 4:47 pm
This type of campaign literature is just plain awful! It plainly sickens me to think that someone, perhaps on the council, and others who live in Maplewood would bend this low. What we do NOT need now is negative campaigning of any type. Our city has been in such disarray for so long, we need to be more respectful and therefore healing. That is the Christian way, now, isn’t it?
I am a resident of Maplewood and am wondering just what does the fact that he is gay and was not born in Maplewood have ANYTHING to do with his running for our council. One does not go with the other at all. Think about this! I mean, REALLY think about this!
I hope that those who have been doing this negative campaigning will stop, as it is just hurting their own reputations. This is NOT the 70’s, 80’s, or even the 90’s. Homophobia should be old news. Let is not make it a current event!
I will be researching all of the candidates before I vote, but right now I am definitely leaning towards Jim Llanas.
Comment posted October 25, 2009 @ 6:04 pm
Dave, if you didn’t see any racist or homophobic intent in the flier, then I think you must be completely deluded or just downright stupid.
The comment on the human rights council was especially disturbing to me. “Which humans?” indeed! Are only certain humans worthy of having rights? Like, say, white heterosexual male protestants?
Also, what does the fact that this man was hanging out with gay politicians in Minneapolis have to do with anything? They could have made their point that Llanos was hanging out with politicians in Minneapolis to get people to infer that he wasn’t spending enough time in Maplewood. But no, they had to make sure they all knew that the politicians were GAY; ABSOLUTELY, UNABASHEDLY, H.O.M.O.S.E.X.U.A.L.!!! Got it?!
And why do you think that is, Dave? Well, I’ll tell you why. It’s because they’re playing directly upon the fears of bigots. If you can’t see the homophobic intent in that, sir, I would argue that you’re not qualified to run for office. Actually, I pity the poor people of Maplewood if they put you in charge.
Oh, and regarding your first comment; to imply that we should all be race-blind is to deny the struggles and culture that have formed along with racial identities in the United States. It’s offensive and it silences people who continue to experience institutionalized racism every day at the hands of our society and our government.
Comment posted October 25, 2009 @ 10:55 pm
Dave, me thinks you protest too much. I know what that usually means.
And you want us to vote for “the only candidates who are running without an agenda”?? Well I agree with you on that – no agenda, no plan, no credibility. Just trash talk.
Comment posted October 26, 2009 @ 7:29 pm
Thank you, Judy, Shannon, and Lyn for your wonderful comments. Excellently stated. I totally agree. I think that there are most Maplewood residents will not allow the awful negative literature going around, and will make their decision as to who to vote for based on the candidates’ qualities. I have much hope for Maplewood.
As I said before, I will be watching the election night with much anticipation and hope.
Comment posted October 27, 2009 @ 7:52 pm
Mister Hafner, what links #2-6? I can’t find any numbered links. Which page on Llanas’ site are you referring to? Better yet, why don’t you just forthrightly say what you are referring to?
My biggest beef with the likes of Hafner, the anonymous flyer creators and distributors, and a number of others who come before the Council, is not that we disagree — it’s the negativism, the personal put-downs, the inflammatory language. That doesn’t make others want to cooperate with them much.
I can have legitimate disagreements with others and yet speak to them civilly and with respect, if I get the same from them. I think that’s what this election is about more than the issues. I’m supporting 3 people I think can work together and with others, not always agreeing, but without personal attacks.
Have you heard of the Golden Rule?
Read this, apply some of it, then maybe you can play with the big kids: http://www.peace.ca/kindergarten.htm
Comment posted October 30, 2009 @ 6:51 pm
It wasn’t long ago that Minnesota homophobes used the same type of anonymous flyers in attacking Republican State Senator Paul E. Koering of District 12. It didn’t work in Senator Koering’s district, hopefully the voters of Maplewood will be as open minded when they go to the polls next Tuesday.
If I lived in Maplewood I would be proud to have James Llanis represent me on the City Council.
Mike Triggs- Former Executive Director of the Minnesota Republican Party
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL
Leave a comment