Visitors flying into the Twin Cities for the Republican National Convention were, up until last Friday, to be greeted upon arrival by the gigantic face of a U.S. soldier. New York–based artist Suzanne Opton photographed active-duty military personnel and arranged to have their faces appear on five billboards in Minneapolis and St. Paul. One, a 48-footer on Highway 5, was to be positioned at the intersection of Post Road just outside the international airport. But CBS Outdoor cancelled the contract, citing that they feared drivers might misinterpret their message.
In 2004 and 2005, Opton traveled to Fort Drum in her home state to photograph soldiers. “When I saw them on the news I couldn’t really see them,” she told me in a phone call today. “They’re so encumbered with gear you can’t see them.”
At the time, her son was of draft age, and getting to know around 90 military volunteers got her thinking: If her son was in the military, how would it change his life?
The billboards, part of her “Soldiers Billboard Project,” show soldiers facing the viewer, with their heads positioned on a table, as if at rest. The pose suggests vulnerability, a trait in direct opposition to public perceptions of those in the armed forces. “I wanted to turn the idea of a soldier on its head and look at them as vulnerable.”
“I wanted to look in the face of a young person who has seen something that has marked their lives,” she said. “Whether or not you can see that in the photograph is another matter.”
Apparently CBS Outdoor execs saw something else. They contacted Opton and local sponsor Forecast Public Art and shared their concerns. First, the issue was that it wasn’t clear who paid for the ad or that it was art. One CBS account executive said that there’s paranoia about the RNC and that she wanted to make sure that the billboards had a clear sponsor logo and URL so that it wouldn’t be mistaken for “some weird subversive website,” Opton recalls.
Then, in an email to Opton, CBS Outdoor Executive Vice President of Marketing Jodi Senese said that she was concerned that “out-of-context (neither in a museum setting or website) the images, as stand-alone highway or city billboards, appear to be deceased soldiers. The presentation in this manner could be perceived as being disrespectful to the men and women in our armed forces.”
Opton, who assures that the soldiers are alive and well and gave consent to be part of the project, fielded queries and with Forecast came up with alternative versions of the ad, but CBS wouldn’t accept them.
Opton says the project is part of a larger one: After her Fort Drum series, she traveled to Jordan and began photographing Iraqis who had fled when war broke out in their homeland. The complete “Soldiers and Citizens” series carries a message that civilians and soldiers are both victims of war. But she insists that the project is “not an antiwar statement by any means.”
“Whether people are in favor of this war — or any war — or against it, we all know that people get killed and that war puts people in harm’s way,” she said. “It doesn’t matter what your view of war is.”
A mother of one of the featured individuals concurs; her son — who, according to Opton’s site served in 353 days in Iraq and in 205 in Afghanistan — is shown in the first photo above. “Viewing these portraits of soldiers causes one to pause and think of the many sacrifices and efforts these men and women have experienced to protect us and defend this great country. The portraits are a stark reminder of the reality of it all.” Gayanne Birkholz said in a statement. “For me, looking at their faces serves also as a reminder to remember our service men and women and to thank them for all they do and have done. I am disappointed that the billboards have been canceled, and strongly hope the company will reconsider.”
While the project won’t be seen here, elements of it are currently on view at art museums in Brooklyn and Austin, Tex. Soldiers and Citizens will be shown at St. Lawrence University next winter.
The billboards, shown below with the soldiers’ names and intended location of billboard, would’ve been seen by 2,815,400 people, had CBS not cancelled the contract — and that doesn’t include RNC visitors.
Update: Army of One: ‘Soldier’ billboard that CBS nixed finds new home








20 Comments »
Comment posted August 27, 2008 @ 2:25 pm
Wow, art that provokes thought? I understand why CBS would want to kill that.
Comment posted August 27, 2008 @ 2:41 pm
Thats nuts
Comment posted August 27, 2008 @ 2:46 pm
Why is the face of war being suppressed by some billboard corporation? Why should they get to decide what we see?
Comment posted August 27, 2008 @ 4:23 pm
Looks like ad copy from the back section of the City Pages. Thank goodness someone had the sense to pull the plug.
Comment posted August 27, 2008 @ 4:27 pm
Um, because they were paying for it?
Comment posted August 27, 2008 @ 4:48 pm
Thanksbutno–The artist–or her sponsor–was paying for this billboard, so again, why is CBS censoring it? And what “subversive organizations” does it fear? You wearmongers really can't stand debate or dissension can you? Why not just declare martial law and get it over with?
Comment posted August 27, 2008 @ 5:33 pm
Well, I submit that before a debate with us “wearmongers” can begin, a thorough review of the subject material is in order for you.
“First, the issue was that it wasn’t clear who paid for the ad…”
Comment posted August 27, 2008 @ 5:57 pm
The issue was the clarity of visual presentation of a sponsor logo, not about who funded the media buy. But, to be clear: Opton's team paid for the ad using money it raised in partnership with the New York Foundation for the Arts (NYFA), which acted as its fiscal sponsor. Forecast was the local partner/sponsor.
Comment posted August 27, 2008 @ 8:51 pm
How many times have you driven by a billboard and wondered who the hell put that up? Plenty. How many have had their contract revoked? Few, if any, I would guess. This is a very ugly world we've entered with this kind of shit. Arresting people for having cameras on public property. Intimidation of film crews. Billboard censoring. Is this the kind of “freedom” political conventions are supposed to be celebrating?
Comment posted August 28, 2008 @ 10:26 am
Could anyone have really failed to anticipate that people with only time for a quick glance might think these looked like photos of deceased soldiers? In a gallery this might appear very different but I don't actually think the artist and sponsor are that naive. There is an unacknowledged message here. And just as an FYI, private companies exercise discretion all the time when accepting or rejecting ad material. I may often disagree with the decision that is made but since CBS isn't the government (yet) it isn't “censorship” but discretion. Just like the Star Tribune wouldn't accept ads for the Pioneer Press.
Comment posted August 28, 2008 @ 10:39 am
CBS is pure crap on this issue. They must have had sufficient time to do their research and to view the pictures and make a determination as to the intent of the advertising. This is pure nonsense. If I was the artist and Option I would take CBS to court for violating their contract. There is no excuse for CBS and someone from the screwball Republican Party got to CBS. Consider the fact that CBS altered the interview with McCain to protect him–what can one expect.
Comment posted August 28, 2008 @ 12:46 pm
Breathtaking. And very evocative. You , at first, might think they are dead, but then you look at the eyes and you see they are very alive, but what they are seeing is profoundly elusive.T
Comment posted August 28, 2008 @ 1:25 pm
Since when in the last 8 yrs have we had freedom to do anything and not get arrested. Welcome to the World of Hitler lite (Bush). I have seen with my own eyes if you have an opinion you are told to shut up. It happened to me at work.
Comment posted August 28, 2008 @ 2:25 pm
Yeah, we definitely can't have anyone thinking. Imagine the rampant discourse that would result.
Comment posted August 29, 2008 @ 3:45 pm
Another death threat to the First Amendment Rights of WE THE PEOPLE,
can't offend the RNC who are on a mission to obliterate all constitutional rights
except those that fit into their own narrow world.
Comment posted August 30, 2008 @ 6:37 pm
wow. these are pretty disturbing… in a good way….
– tony
Comment posted August 30, 2008 @ 6:59 pm
John McCain missed 10 of the past 14 votes on Iraq?
John McCain in September 2007: voted against the Webb amendment calling for adequate troop rest between deployments?
John McCain in May 2006, voted against an amendment that would provide $20 million to the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) for health care facilities?
John McCain in April 2006, was one of only 13 Senators to vote against $430,000,000 for the Department of Veteran Affairs for Medical Services for outpatient care and treatment for veterans?
John McCain in March 2006, voted against increasing Veterans medical services funding by $1.5 billion in FY 2007 to be paid for by closing corporate tax loopholes?
John McCain in March 2004, once again voted for abusive tax loopholes over veterans when he voted against creating a reserve fund to allow for an increase in Veterans' medical care by $1.8 billion by eliminating abusive tax loopholes. Jeez, McCain really loves those tax loopholes for corporations, since he voted for them over our veterans' needs?
John McCain in October 2003, voted to table an amendment by Senator Dodd that called for an additional $322,000,000 for safety equipment for United States forces in Iraq and to reduce the amount provided for reconstruction in Iraq by $322,000,000?
John McCain in April 2003, urged other Senate members to table a vote (which never passed) to provide more than $1 billion for National Guard and Reserve equipment in Iraq related to a shortage of helmets, tents, bullet-proof inserts, and tactical vests?
Comment posted September 2, 2008 @ 8:33 pm
These are beautiful. They remind us that these soldiers are ordinary people, giving their lives for our country (whether or not you believe in the war).
Comment posted September 2, 2008 @ 9:57 pm
Looks like they are all hungover!
Comment posted September 2, 2008 @ 10:40 pm
This was such a good idea. To bad CBS is not as brave as these guys.
RSS feed for comments on this post.
Leave a comment