10 ways insurance companies will get out of reforming
Wednesday, March 31, 2010 at 2:14 pm
If you thought that the health care reform bill was so expertly thought through as to prevent health insurance companies from engaging in the same end run around regulation practiced by the credit card companies, then Dan Froomkin has some news for you: You’re naive. Far be it from insurance companies to spend the next four years until the implementation of health care reform begins figuring out how to operate under a new regulatory framework; instead, they’ll use their massive profits to figure out as many ways as possible to screw their customers before the rules go into effect, and as many ways as possible to get out of complying with the new rules.
Let us count the ways.
1. Raising premiums
There is absolutely, positively no prohibition on companies raising premiums at outrageous rates until 2014 — so they’re not going to stop. And politicians in Washington might scream, but the volume will be far less next year because the President won’t have a reform bill to pass.
2. Kicking people out for pre-existing conditions
The insurance industry may have relented about using pre-existing conditions to determine children’s eligibility, but they’re not about to let adults with pre-existing conditions qualify for insurance coverage one minute sooner than 2014 — and the way they floated the idea that the law didn’t really totally require them to accept children with pre-existing conditions is a hint that they’re desperately looking for a similar loophole in 2014 and beyond.
3. Changing your insurance plan
Remember how President Obama said that if you liked your insurance plan, you wouldn’t have to change? Well, the health reform bill won’t make you, but your insurance company might. They’re busy shutting down and restricting access to managed care plans (HMOs) and pushing current customers into high-deductible plans, where customers have to pay all expenses out of pocket before the insurance company picks up a dime. In other words, customers pay a (relatively) small premium each month and then the first $2,500 of their health care each year before the insurance company begins to cover a percentage of the costs of their medical care.
4. Making life more difficult for doctors
One great way to reduce insurance company payouts is to make it more difficult for doctors to file claims, which insurance companies are already planning on doing.
5. Tightening up internal practices
That’s a euphemism for giving patients and doctors enough of a run-around trying to get bills paid to convince them to give up asking for reimbursements.
6. Marketing only to healthy people
Healthy people are the cheapest to insure, and people tend to gravitate toward marketing materials that look like them. But if they make certain drugs hard (or impossible) to find on pharmaceutical formularies, or put up physical barriers to obtaining the insurance, they can (and likely will) keep more elderly and sick people from even applying for their insurance.
7. Re-label current overhead expenses at health care
When the reform finally takes full effect in 2014, insurance companies will have to spend 80 percent of their premiums on care for their customers. Thus, in order to make more money, they’ll have to increase the money you spend on care, or figure out a way to classify expenses currently deemed “overhead” as “health care for you.” Luckily, they’ve got an army of lawyers and accountants more than willing to assist.
8. Taking full advantage of the unhealthy behavior premium
In the reform, insurers are allowed to makes premiums 50 percent more expensive for consumers who engage in “unhealthy” behaviors, which was intended to allow them to continue charging smokers higher premiums. But there are lots of behaviors deemed “unhealthy.” Have more than one sexual partner? Neglect to get 30 minutes of cardiovascular exercise a day? Love sweets? Drink carbonated, caffeinated sodas? All those behaviors, and many more, are considered risky by the medical profession and could make your insurance far more expensive than you think.
9. Charging old people as much as they can
The law allows insurers to charge people between 55 and 65 (the current age of Medicare eligibility) three times more than people 54 and under. So on their fifty-fifth birthdays, some customers could get new, higher insurance bills that put readjusted mortgage bills to shame — and there won’t be anything remotely illegal about it.
10. Lobbying to make the most of the loopholes that exist and create others
It likely goes without saying that all the money and lobbying time that went into watering down health care reform and trying to keep it from passing aren’t just going to stop flowing to Washington. Rather, as the Department of Health and Human Services spends its time promulgating rules to govern the various reforms in the bill, lobbyists will simply switch their focus from the Hill to HHS. We know what they want — to limit the effect reform will have on their bottom line — and they know how they’ll get it: through the regulatory process.
6 Comments
Comment posted March 31, 2010 @ 6:57 pm
Insurance companies will never stop trying to find ways to make more, paying out less. When will citizens realize Single Payer is the only option for real reform? Afraid of government screwing you?? What are the insurance companies doing to you? At least government cannot make a profit! They just need to be held to the rug or the letter of the law to leaven funds alone and not use them to support wars and everything else!
Comment posted April 1, 2010 @ 9:28 am
What HCR? It is really HIR – and a lame one, at that. Health Insurance Reform. I’ve seen nothing to indicate that this HIR will address many of the fundamental flaws in the way health care is delivered here in these States. What we really need is truly tranformative HCR, and the only way to accomplish that is to establish a single-payer, universal health care system financed perhaps by a national sales tax. Such a system would totally replace the current, broken infrastructure including employer mandates; health insurance companies; various government programs including Medicaid, GAMC and VA; and so on. There would no longer be a need for medical provisions in homeowners and auto policies. Health professionals can go back to the business of providing health care full-time. People will no longer waste hours and hours poring over health plan details as well as being tied up on the phone fighting with insurance company representatives to get this or that covered. People won’t have to worry about getting medical care when traveling within the States. All children and veterans will get the care they need. Such a system will necessarily have to be financed by an independent agency so that it is not subject to political influences, and yet the agency will be held accountable to ensure that the new system continues to improve and be responsive to the needs of us citizens. Simplify, simplify, and then keep it simple! MEDICARE FOR ALL!
Comment posted April 1, 2010 @ 9:46 am
By removing employer mandates, the employees would no longer be subject to the limited choices offered by human resources with those choices changing every year. And by removing healthcare as a business expense, the playing field will be much more level between American companies and businesses elsewhere who do not have to provide health benefits due to national healthcare.\
Additionally, this new system can include prescription drug and dental coverage. Within the constraints of individual privacy, this system will also be completely transparent in what will be covered along with other important details such as finances, health outcomes by procedure as well as by health provider/installation, and so on. I am sure there’s plenty of other ideas that can be incorporated in such a system so long as it benefits all of us Americans.
Comment posted April 1, 2010 @ 2:15 pm
All this mess just because 15% of the population doesn’t have insurance. What a waste.
Comment posted April 5, 2010 @ 1:03 am
1)Raise premiums? Yes. The bill requires no limits on lifetime expenses and more things covered, =higher cost
2)Prexisting conditions? Does anyone honestly think this wont be changed to start sooner? Equals higher premiums
3)Changing insurance? Any plan that doesn’t meet the new as yet to be written requirements will be illegal. It looks like high deductibles with HSA’s will be illegal.
4)Make life difficult for doctor’s? Harder than the 6 to 9 months it takes medicare to pay? And the 21% cuts?
8)You mean insurance companies might copy the government in trying to punish people for what they eat or smoke like Mayor Bloomberg? Like nanny state Politicians?
9) Currently over 55 folks pay 7 to 8 times higher premiums. Those wont change but young peoples will double or triple to get to the new ratio of only 3 times higher.
My old boss was paying over $1500 a month for insurance. He retired and now buys over $600 a month of private insurance to cover what medicare doesn’t. We don’t even know what the government requirements for policies is yet. According to President Obama we have in the last month gone from 32 million uninsured Americans to 50 million uninsured Americans. Wow! 18 million more without insurance since the bill was signed.
RSS feed for comments on this post.
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.






