Target, Best Buy and 3M get downgraded in HRC equality rating
Tuesday, October 05, 2010 at 12:35 pm
In the new 2011 Corporate Equality Index (CEI) released by the Human Rights Campaign (HRC), three Minnesota corporations’ ratings were decreased due to political activity. Target, Best Buy and 3M all were given an 85-point rating after each received a 15-point reduction for their donations to independent expenditure group MN Forward.
Those donations were protested by LGBT-rights groups as Emmer opposes civil rights measures and has ties to a controversial Christian rock band. In last year’s index, each of those company received a perfect score. The HRC had already announced that Target and Best Buy would be dropped from the organization’s buying guide.
In judging U.S. businesses, the CEI measures a number of factors such as non-discrimination policies, providing partner benefits to same-sex couples and diversity training. They also include a category titled “responsible citizenship,” worth 15 points, that examines whether corporations have “a large-scale official or public anti-LGBT blemish on their recent records.” Best Buy, Target and 3M were granted perfect scores in all categories except the responsible citizenship measure, where all three lost the full 15 points.
In July, Target and Best Buy contributed $150,000 and $100,000 respectively to MN Forward, an independent group that has spent almost all of their funds running advertisements supporting Republican gubernatorial candidate Tom Emmer or attacking Mark Dayton, the Democrat in the race. 3M joined the list of MN Forward donors in September, contributing $100,000 to the organization. Progressive organizations had been largely mute on that latest donation until the new edition of the CEI.
Explaining the downgrade in the three companies’ ratings, the HRC’s report says:
This summer, it came to light that Target Corp., Best Buy Co. Inc. and 3m Co. – all of which had outstanding workplace policies and 100 percent scores on the CEI – had donated substantial sums to an independent expenditure committee supporting an anti-LGBT gubernatorial candidate. HRC confronted the companies about their donations, which could help block marriage equality in Minnesota if this candidate is elected. In doing so, HRC highlighted the dangers of a post-Citizens United world and channeled the LGBT community’s anger toward what HRC hoped would be a reasonable solution. As of this writing, the companies have chosen to take no corrective action and are being penalized under the existing CEI criteria not for the donation itself, but for failing to respond to significant community concerns.
The downgrade for Target, Best Buy and 3M was outside the general trend for U.S. companies in the CEI. The report granted a perfect rating to 337 businesses, an increase from the 2010 CEI, which gave a 100 percent rating to 305 companies.
Patrick Caldwell is the American Independent’s Minnesota correspondent.
6 Comments
Comment posted October 5, 2010 @ 4:51 pm
HAHAHA. I am thrilled that Target and Best Buy (read: MinnesotaForward) are being downgraded. They deserve it. I am sorry for their fine, non-bigoted, employees and I hope they don’t suffer for their CEOs’ bad faith and bad actions. Tom Emmer is behind in the polls. All I can say is thank God (and I do mean God). And thank you, the people of Minnesota for rising above this terrible man and seeing him for what he is. People like Tom Emmer give Christians and Christ a bad name and shame us with their rhetoric, hate mongering and the persecution of minorities. They are the main reason for people leaving the church in droves, the main reason for the climate of hate that drives gay children to suicide (including three Minnesota teens), they are behind the murder of Matthew Shepard, the oppression of people of other religions and the tide of hate and fear that is present in our country. We are Americans, we are better than Tom Emmer and his ilk. They constitute the American Taliban, destroying anyone unlike them. I pray daily for them and ask God to help them awaken from their madness. God Bless America and my fellow Americans (ALL of them).
Comment posted October 5, 2010 @ 5:30 pm
I wouldn’t assume that all organizations that get the 100% rating are necessarily all that great. I know of one personally that gets 100%, but disparaging comments about gays are not uncommon and go unchallenged, including by managment. Always be wary of corporate “image” and what companies will do or spend to create it.
Comment posted October 5, 2010 @ 6:25 pm
Now that corporations are officially people, I welcome the coming day when Red Chinese (yes, the Chinese government is communist) buy a few companies incorporated in the U.S. and start spending money to influence U.S. elections. Right, now, they are doing it indirectly through their agents like Walmart and Target, whose interests are completely tied to Chinese interests. The same with Islamic forces from the Middle East, they’ll turn that oil money into direct political influence simply by incorporating in Delaware. Thanks to your neighborhood radical right wing, our elections can now be directly influenced by “foreign agents” acting as “corporate persons”.
The look of stupidity and shock on right wing faces when that day arrives will, unfortunately, be my only comfort.
Comment posted October 6, 2010 @ 1:04 pm
This is the same group that has tried to indoctrinate children with sexually identity issues – against the parent’s right to protect their children from these dangerous ideas.
“the largest homosexual activist group in the nation, the Human Rights
Campaign, had recently piloted a pro-gay curriculum called Welcoming Schools for elementary-age kids in some Minnesota schools (and elsewhere in the nation).
The Human Rights Campaign claims that this curriculum is all about teaching “diversity” and preventing “name calling.” But lesson plans within the curriculum—such as the “Family Diversity Photo Puzzle”— reveal that it’s
more about indoctrination. For instance, the “Diversity Photo Puzzle,” designed for kids in the first through third grades, gives children puzzle pieces depicting photographs of people.
Children are told to arrange the photos into seven families. But lo and behold, after they begin the assignment, they find themselves forced to “create some families with adults of the same gender” and to “make decisions about whether to label the adults as two mothers,” explains the lesson plan guide. It’s difficult to find a more
blatant example of indoctrination than that.10
When parents in Minnesota found out about this exercise, they not only asked for it to be removed from piloted curricula—but they also worked to defeat the so-called “Safe Schools” law so that it could not be used to push more indoctrination tools like this into classrooms. Their concerns were not hypothetical: In a document entitled “A Look at Laws & Policies That Support
Welcoming Schools,” the Human Rights Campaign has singled out states that have “Safe School Laws” and “Policies Against Harassment and Bullying” as places that may be more open to this curriculum.11″
http://www.truetolerance.org/politicizedbullyingpolicies.pdf
They are not interesting in human rights; they are anti-parents rights and are clearly trying to indoctrinate children, shame on them and anyone that supports this group of tyrants.
Comment posted October 6, 2010 @ 4:56 pm
The things people do to spread their lies and mistruths. Welcoming Schools is nothing what Tim claims. The program was initiated by a group of parents and educators and is based on research that shows links between academic achievement, mental well-being and an inclusive school climate. The site Tim cites is from Focus on the Family. Need I say more?
Pingback posted November 1, 2010 @ 7:04 am
[...] For other corporations the answer is a yes. After seeing the backlash faced by Target and Best Buy, shoe manufacture Red Wing Shoe Company still decided to make a $50,000 contribution to MNForward and 3M, the maker of Post-its, donated $100,000. For these companies the benefit of a political contribution outweighed the risk of a negative reaction. [...]
RSS feed for comments on this post.
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.







