voterfelony

As Ellison decries tea party ‘voter intimidation’ efforts, data shows fraud is rare

In Hennepin County, .006 percent of 2008 votes were cast by felons
By Andy Birkey
Wednesday, October 27, 2010 at 9:30 am

“Voter fraud. It’s a felony.” So reads the “wanted” poster–style type on new fliers being distributed by Republican and tea party groups ahead of election day. What they don’t say is it’s also exceedingly rare. As Democratic Rep. Keith Ellison characterizes such efforts as “voter intimidation” — citing distribution of posters in traditionally DFL-leaning areas like college campuses and bus stops in lower-income neighborhoods — Hennepin County provides the Minnesota Independent with data that shows only .006 percent of votes cast in 2008 were done so fraudulently.

Three conservative groups — Minnesota Majority, the North Star Tea Party Patriots, and the Minnesota Voters Alliance — have partnered to launch Election Integrity Watch (EIW), a project that advocates for voter identification laws and blames ACORN and DFLers for advancing voter fraud in Minnesota. The groups will be watching for voter fraud by sending teams of volunteers to the polls next Tuesday to shoot photos or videos of buses arriving at polling places, challenge voting and monitor assisted-living communities. EIW is offering a $500 reward to anyone who provides evidence that leads to a conviction for illegal voting.

EIW’s activities are part of a national campaign, and allegations of voter intimidation are already cropping up in early voting states including Texas and Florida.

They’re also behind the  fliers and advertisements showing a handcuffed man that Rep. Ellison says is part of a voter-intimidation campaign.

“To scare people is wrong,” Ellison said at a press conference at Minneapolis City Hall Tuesday. “There’s not going to be anybody putting you in handcuffs.”

“This is not about voter fraud. It’s about voter intimidation,” he said. “Our proud history of civic participation is under threat from shadowy groups who are attempting to scare people away from the polls. In reality, Minnesota’s voter protection laws are strong, and our state has many organizations and tools to assure that people can exercise their right to vote — free of intimidation.”

Ellison then invited to the podium experts who spoke about voting in minority communities, voters who have had their civil rights restored and students who talked about voting on campus. Ellison is focusing on educating voters about their rights at the polls. TheUptake has video of the press conference:

[Story continues after video]

Illegal voting is rare in Minnesota, but EIW and tea party groups aren’t taking any chances. The conservative group Minnesota Majority launched a major initiative last year to get illegal voters prosecuted and targeted Minnesota’s two DFL strongholds — Hennepin and Ramsey counties.

Jeff Johnson, a Republican Hennepin County Commissioner, pressed county attorney Mike Freeman recently about the 899 names that Minnesota Majority submitted in 2009. That group’s allegation was that widespread voter fraud cost Republican Sen. Norm Coleman the election, a claim that was picked up by Fox News this summer.

Hennepin County Attorney Mike Freeman wrote back (PDF) saying that his office looked into Minnesota Majority’s accusations and found that illegal voting is rare.

“The rate of chargeable cases in Hennepin County of felons voting who have not had their rights restored in the 2008 election is .00006,” wrote Freeman. “Evidence of any other type of voter fraud was insufficient to bring any charges at all.”

His office charged 47 people with illegally voting in 2008. Seven of those came from election officials and 40 from Minnesota Majority’s data. Freeman wrote that the bulk information provided by Minnesota Majority was either insufficient or inaccurate.

In Ramsey County, 28 have been charged with illegal voting.

Despite the low number of charges, Rep. Michele Bachmann rallied the tea party effort on the Glenn Beck Show on Tuesday evening, claiming that a coordinated effort to get felons to vote helped Sen. Al Franken win the 2008 election.

“And remember we had the infamous felons for Franken program two years ago where we know that there were felons that went out and voted presumably for Al Franken,” she said. “We had more felons vote than the margin of vote victory for Al Franken. So there are over about 350 felons or 600, somewhere in that neighborhood, that were eligible to vote. We know that about 350 did vote. And Al Franken won by just barely over 300 votes.”

Freeman said his office’s investigation found no evidence of a coordinated effort to get felons to vote.

“There was no organized or coordinated effort to induce improper voting. There was no involvement of any campaign or any candidate. And there were no cases charged of non-citizens improperly voting.”

Follow Andy Birkey on Twitter


Comments

38 Comments

Dan McGrath
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 10:28 am

Notice anything missing from that “poster” Rep. Ellison keeps holding up? The “poster” is a doctored version of the bus shelter ads – the following has been removed from Ellison’s version:

ElectionIntegrityWatch.com
Report fraud by calling
877-602-WATCH

And he goes on to claim that the “poster” was produced by some shadowy anonymous organization. If only he hadn’t doctored the image, he could have read the organization’s name and website and even a phone number.

The message, “report voter fraud by calling…” is as intimidating to the law abiding as Neighborhood Watch signs that say if I don’t call police, my neighbor will.”

Why don’t you ask Rep. Ellison why he doctored up that image, lied about it’s origins and attempted to obscure it’s intent.

Why don’t you also review ElectionIntegrityWatch.com and actually learn about the program before commenting on how horrible it is. People are going to WATCH. That has some people very agitated, which suggests to me they are up to something they don’t want seen.

90% of the voter fraud that’s been caught in the 2008 election would have gone undetected without Minnesota Majority’s independent research, so obviously citizen involvement is needed to uphold the laws. Hennepin County acknowledges they missed most of it. Do you have a problem with upholding our election laws?

Now, how about a dose of honesty?


Denizen
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 10:29 am

Voter fraud is rare, only one party does it, the Democrats.


Dan McGrath
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 10:29 am

And by the way, you can see the entire (undoctored, uncropped) bus shelter ad here: http://www.electionintegritywatch.com/advertisements/


Dennis
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 10:33 am

The biggest fraud in this story is Ellison.


Paul Schmelzer
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 10:38 am

How is cropping, “doctoring”?


Rod
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 11:09 am

Who is getting elected? Aren’t votes from basketcase nations Somalia and Mexico enough for the likes of Ellison, no, then they have to bring in Fraudulent Votes? But it’s okay for the Democrats to be bigots and discrminate Tom Emmer out of a restuarant on Lake Street.

Ellison types are the true bigots.

Hey, read http://www.blogdelnarco.com/ to see what Mexico today is really like. Wow, don’t we want to end up like that.


bill.e.goat
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 11:40 am

The biggest fraud in this comment thread is Dennis.


Randy
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 12:03 pm

“90% of the voter fraud that’s been caught in the 2008 election would have gone undetected without Minnesota Majority’s independent research . . .”

Impressive stat. How many cases were there (not a percentage–I wnat to know the number)?


Amuseinc
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 12:21 pm

Seems like to a Republican if you can’t win an election you just have to scream about it being stolen. Well I’m sorry but the GOP lost in Minnesota in 2008 and it is about to lose big in 2010 because Minnesota citizens want nothing to do with your craziness. If you were running someone like Arnie Carlson instead of Extremist Emmer you might have a complaint….

Dennis read a book once in a while you wild eyed accusations are boring.


Dennis
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 1:08 pm

“If you were running someone like Arnie Carlson …”

we’d be democrats.


EricF
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 2:16 pm

After Kenneth Blackwell, Tim Griffin et al, it’s amazing Republicans would accuse anyone else. Meanwhile, you can’t find more than a few cases of felons who probably thought their rights were restored. Clarify that by restoring their rights when they leave prison, and even in a county with as many votes as Hennepin, you can count the fraud on one hand.

And still Republicans, you have zero evidence of organized fraud. Any apologies coming?


Dennis
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 3:13 pm

After this cycle’s polling place anti-fraud efforts by Tea Party volunteers, I expect attempted voter fraud to be a big story on Nov. 3rd.


Tim
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 4:12 pm

“Denial isn’t just a river in Egypt.

It’s the Democrats’ coping mechanism for midterm election voter fraud. Faced with multiple reports of early voting irregularities and election shenanigans across the country, left-wing groups are playing dumb, deaf and blind. Voter fraud? What voter fraud?”

“More cunningly, these organizations are seeking to marginalize complaints about election integrity by casting citizen watchdog efforts as racist “scare tactics.” Echoing President Obama’s message to the Democratic faithful on the campaign trail, they are accusing political opponents of suppressing the votes of minorities and the poor.”

This flies in the face of dozens of felony voter fraud convictions across the country over the past two election cycles — and that’s just among ACORN-tied cases.

“In North Carolina and Nevada, early voters have encountered ballot machine glitches that favor Democrats in hotly contested races.

In Troy, New York, and Daytona Beach, Florida, police investigations into suspected absentee ballot fraud by elected government officials are under way.

In Harris County, Texas, the voter registrar admitted that 20 percent of voter registration forms submitted by liberal activist Houston Votes had problems.”

http://www.onenewsnow.com/Perspectives/Default.aspx?id=1217558


Randy
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 5:05 pm

Notice the race of the person who is front and center in the poster.

“Boy, I’d better not catch you tryin’ to vote again.”

To Tim: Michelle Malkin couldn’t convince me it was raining if her hair was soaking wet. Try to do better than quoting such an outright fraud.


Dennis
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 6:51 pm

“Michelle Malkin couldn’t convince me it was raining if her hair was soaking wet.”

Why, because she’s not white?


Glynis
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 8:34 pm

“polling place anti-fraud efforts by Tea Party volunteers”. Exactly what might those be Dennis? You do realize that they are not allowed to hang around in the polling places or within 100 feet of the polling places. They are not allowed to question voters in the polling places. The only people who can talk to voters within 100 feet outside the polling place are exit pollers and that is only after they vote and only to ask if they want to fill out an anonymous questionnaire. No voter has to talk to them or show them anything. If they are acting aggressively toward voters they can be removed from the premises by law enforcement. So what “efforts” are they taking to prevent voter fraud?


Glynis
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 8:37 pm

Bachmann is such an idiot. The felon they interviewed last year said he voted for Coleman. The lengths this woman will go is beyond disgusting. Boy would I love to see one of those Clark stuns the world moments in her district.


EricF
Comment posted October 27, 2010 @ 8:45 pm

Tim, we don’t have to deny what’s not there. Dig into those stories a little deer if you don’t mind. By the way, problems with registrations aren’t voter fraud. Try to keep up with the rest of the class.


Scott
Comment posted October 28, 2010 @ 8:17 am

Dennis,
It doesn’t matter if Michelle Malkin were Klingon wielding a bat’leth at my head, she still is a liar. So no its not a race issue, it’s a she has no shame in telling lies.


Randy
Comment posted October 28, 2010 @ 9:37 am

“Why, because she’s not white?”

No, because she is a proven liar. Race has nothing to do with it.


Tim
Comment posted October 28, 2010 @ 10:41 am

Michelle has an excellent new book that is on the NY Times Best sellers list.

Culture of Corruption: Obama and His Team of Tax Cheats, Crooks, and Cronies
http://www.amazon.com/Culture-Corruption-Cheats-Crooks-Cronies/dp/1596986204/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1288279871&sr=1-1

The book is full of facts and proven statistics. Rather than calling her a liar, perhaps you just don’t like how she organizes facts.


Randy
Comment posted October 28, 2010 @ 12:48 pm

Oh, a bestseller! That convinces me of nothing other than she was able to hose a bunch of people into buying her book (“And someday, I’m gonna learn me how to read it!”)

I’m sure Michelle “Interning the Japanese Was a Good Idea” Malkin has cleverly arranged facts to support what you and your type want to believe is true. It can cut both ways: to use a favorite Republican ethical non-defense, corruption is endemic on both sides. I could, with little effort, “organize facts” to support an argument that the Republican Party is an unusually lawless faction of the European Kindred. Let’s start with the outright gangsterism of the Nixon Administration, move to the cronyism, larceny, and fraud of the Reagan years, and end up with GW Bush’s lies in support of his Oedipal actings-out in Iraq.

Michelle Malkin has a record as a bald-faced liar. I don’t care what she puts in a printed screed.


Dave
Comment posted October 28, 2010 @ 9:14 pm

“.00006 percent of 2008 votes were cast by felons”

The math is off here. Freeman stated that was the rate of felon voting _not the percentage_.

650,000 being 1.00000 the rate would be .00006.

650,000 being 100% the percentage would be .006%

Still small nonetheless.


Dan McGrath
Comment posted October 29, 2010 @ 12:35 am

“How is cropping, “doctoring”?”

Ellison’s poster isn’t cropped. It’s the full image, including the reward notation on the bottom. Things have been edited out of the middle of it.

Why couldn’t Ellison make his points without doctoring the image – and, doctored or original, what’s wrong with the message? It’s true. Voter fraud is a felony. What’s wrong with informing people of that fact and warning of the consequences?


Dan McGrath
Comment posted October 29, 2010 @ 12:52 am

“650,000 being 100% the percentage would be .006% Still small nonetheless. 47 fraudulent votes (in Hennepin County alone – there are 86 other counties) is 15% of 312. Why is that significant? That’s the margin of victory in the last US Senate race in Minnesota. Small amounts of fraud have the potential to swing tight elections.

Most of the cases Hennepin declined to prosecute were in fact instances of ineligible votes, but prosecutors didn’t feel they could prove the voter knew he or she was ineligible. That put the ineligible votes in a weird legal limbo. They aren’t legal votes, but there was no crime, according to prosecutors. There were 450 such ineligible votes in Hennepin County alone.

Detecting votes cast by ineligible felons is easy. There’s a list. There is no list of phony names, for example, though. If the government can’t even catch ineligible voters on their own when there’s a list, do you think they can prevent, catch or prosecute other kinds of fraud by themselves? In this state, the word of one person is sufficient to secure ballots for 15 other unidentified, unregistered individuals (insanity).

About 500,000 people registered to vote on election day in 2008. 23,000 of them provided addresses that could not be verified by the county auditors. Postal verification cards (official election mail) mailed to them after their votes were tallied were returned undeliverable. They’ll be flagged for challenge in the next election, but their votes in 2008 have already been counted.


Zera Lee
Comment posted October 29, 2010 @ 1:00 am

Voter suppression is a far bigger problem than voter fraud. Let’s stop the Tea Party from adding to it.


Ann Galloway
Comment posted October 29, 2010 @ 10:24 am

MN has one of the best voting integrity in the nation. I was one of many people who double checked the vote and counts to make sure our voting machines were accurate. It came out in the top upper 90′s percent, which is very high. The Franken/Coleman recount was another example of how well our voting system is.


markmwhite
Comment posted October 29, 2010 @ 10:41 am

Andy Birkey is a fraud. Wow, they caught a handful of felons so there is no problem. if that was the only type of voter fraud there would be no problem. Andy knows of the other types of fraud and he knows that these other types aren’t even being looked at. I guess his point is not to do any journalism but rather to produce propaganda, kudos to you comrade.


markmwhite
Comment posted October 29, 2010 @ 10:43 am

Zera Lee, where is the voter suppression? i suppose a requirement that a voter actually be eligible is suppression?


Scott
Comment posted October 29, 2010 @ 11:22 am

Dan,

So were you this all outraged by what happend with the elections in Florida in 2000 and Ohio in 2004?

Because to me neither of those elections pass the smell test for fraud and abuse.


Scott
Comment posted October 29, 2010 @ 11:26 am

Mark,
Voter suppression is whenever someone is working to discourage someone to vote. It can be as blatently obivious as calls to people saying that one party votes on one day and others on another, like has been done in a number of states. Or like in Florida, where they do not have same day registration, having people improperly removed from the voter roles.

Could you specify other types of voter fraud?


Chris Kumpula
Comment posted October 29, 2010 @ 12:46 pm

How is calling for an end to illegal voting bad? How is demanding that election officials do their jobs and id voters equivalent to voter suppression? What is voter suppression is preventing Election Integrity Watch from attempting to clean up elections in MN.

We are the laughing stock of the country after Franken v. Coleman, but, as susual, liberals do not care about the law or ensuring integrity in elections- they will do anything to win.


Randy Olson
Comment posted October 29, 2010 @ 12:54 pm

Here’s what I sent to “Steve Townsend” – one of the leaders of this bogus attempt to stifle the vote next week:

Steve,

I will be monitoring election precincts in my area, and if I see any voter intimidation tactics going on, they will be documented and reported to the police immediately.

Have a nice day.

Randy Olson
Herman-Hoffman Tribune managing editor


Dan McGrath
Comment posted October 29, 2010 @ 4:37 pm

Randy – welcome to the Election Integrity Watch team! That’s exactly what we’re doing! You can learn more about the program you’ve volunteered for (and how to spot other illegal election activity here: http://www.electionintegritywatch.com/watch-list/

After you’re done helping watch for illegal activities on election day, are you going to write or edit a non-biased and factual article for the Herman-Hoffman Tribune about the effort? Since you are participating and helping create the news, best make it an editorial, right?

Nobody want to defend Rep. Ellison’s handiwork anymore? What happened?


Todd Dugdale
Comment posted October 30, 2010 @ 10:32 pm

Tim wrote:
“Faced with multiple reports of early voting irregularities and election shenanigans across the country, left-wing groups are playing dumb, deaf and blind.”

Oooh, multiple cases. And then he explains that “dozens” have been prosecuted already.
First, if they are prosecuted, then that is not really “playing deaf, dumb, and blind”, is it?

Second, if we believe your “dozens” of instances in a nation of 308 million, then explain how “dozens” of fraudulent voters can tip any national election.

Third, you are mixing registration fraud and voter fraud together. Sure, people register as ‘Mickey Mouse”, but they don’t actually show up at the polls and vote.

Fourth, as the story clearly states, a convicted felon CAN vote if their rights are restored. Quoting figures of convicted felons who voted is meaningless without knowing how many of those have their rights restored. Fortunately, this was examined by Freeman. The result was slightly more than three dozen. And we don’t even know who those people voted for. You seem to imply that this tipped the balance in the Senate race. Arithmetic must not be your strong subject.

Notice that there was no evidence found of illegal aliens voting, or hundreds of voters being driven around for multiple voting, or of any kind of conspiracy whatsoever. But that doesn’t stop you from claiming those things.


commenter
Comment posted November 1, 2010 @ 3:26 am

The frenzied opposition to this ‘election integrity’ group proves that the group will find nothing amiss.

…right?


cyberpol
Comment posted November 3, 2010 @ 1:31 pm

No, that poster was not doctored. They purposely leave out any information when posting information on the site, but not for the reasons you are claiming. What an obtuse remark. Yeah, seen one of those who were sent in to watch the voting and he did nothing but create problems – problems that were not true. Every single voter that showed up and saw that wanted him thrown out. All citizens from all party’s. See how much we don’t like the hyper driven effort of false accusations?

You know something, I watched Coleman/Franken court case – he didn’t have a damn thing, and in the end – he only upset more people for his games. Franken not only won fair and sqaure, but he actually gave voting districts to Coleman in the court case. He had many more votes in the end.


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.