I was going to call it a night. After nearly three hours of observing the cat-and-mouse game between protesters and police the scene was starting to get tiresome. (Best protester chant of the night: “You’re hot, you’re cute, take off your riot suit.”)
I planned to meet a friend for a drink at the Great Waters Brewing Company in downtown St. Paul. But this notion was foiled by the fact that dozens of cops in riot gear were blocking the bridge at Rice Street and John Ireland Boulevard. “There’s an explosive device that the bomb squad is investigating,” we were told. Other routes into downtown were also being blocked by police officers. There seemed to be no route out of the chaos.
So I headed north towards University Avenue, where the protesters appeared to be gravitating. A cloud of smoke could be seen near the Greyhound bus station. I broke into a jog through the Sears parking lot with a crowd of folks to see what was happening. Cops on bicycles were swarming all around. Soon the smoke was accompanied by percussive grenades.
As I approached the west end of the Sears building, deafening blasts began echoing all around me. A cop on a megaphone barked an order: “This is the police department. Your main method of leaving is southbound.”
I retreated in a crowd towards the Marion Street bridge over I-94. Police officers in riot gear, wielding cans of mace, followed closely behind. “You’re gonna get sprayed if you don’t move,” they stated repeatedly through their gas masks. Then more percussive grenades and smoke bombs, this time in the direction we were being directed by the cops to travel. So I turned and headed east, only to be confronted by more deafening blasts.
Eventually I ended up at the edge of the Marion Street bridge. The person directly in front of me approached an officer, explaining that he was trying to get to work. The cop’s response: “Move your feet. You should have left a long time ago.”
As we walked across the bridge, an officer addressed the crowd through a megaphone. “Sit down and put your hands on your head,” he said. “If you are on this bridge, you are under arrest.” Each end of the span was now surrounded by dozens of cops in riot gear. There were roughly (and this a highly arbitrary estimate) 400 people on the bridge.
After about fifteen minutes, the officers began searching and handcuffing everyone on the bridge. “Hands on your head,” they repeatedly barked, cans of mace at the ready. A gentleman a few feet away from me — who I believe was a journalist — informed the officers that he was carrying a gun as they began to arrest him. They pulled him away from the crowd and a team of cops searched him and presumably removed the weapon.
Not long afterwards I was restrained in plasticuffs, thoroughly searched and seated on a sidewalk with other people who were being detained. My status as a journalist meant that I did not spend much time in cuffs. They segregated reporters and legal observers from the rest of the detainees. Our handcuffs were removed and we were seated on a grass median. Metro Transit buses were waiting to transport the not-so-fortunate others, presumably to the Ramsey County Jail.
Eventually I was placed in a van with eight others. We were driven across the Sears parking lot, given a citation for unlawful assembly and released. I got to keep my pair of plasticuffs as a souvenir. But the cops still have two of my pens.

















22 Comments »
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 1:33 am
What happened to the Twin Cities? I can't believe I'm reading about the place where I live.
A lesson here is that aggressiveness and disorganization are a bad combination in riot police.
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 7:05 am
Unlawful assembly? It's a sad day in America.
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 8:13 am
It sounds like these police deliberately attempted to confuse and fool people who happened to be present in the area to prevent their movement from leaving with a plan to maximize arrests. The CityAdministrations of St. Paul and Minneapolis and the State have a lot to answer for in this wasted RNC spectacle.
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 8:59 am
Unlawful assembly is just a stronger, more bullshity way of saying inconvenient to commuters or bad for publicity.
Everything I've read about this incident leads me to believe the cops were just manipulating the crowd in order to produce arrests. There was no where for them to go. I still haven't heard that the crowd caused any damage or committed any real crime.
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 9:30 am
thanks for the great reporting. worst idea this city has ever had. c. coleman has lost my vote for sure….
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 10:34 am
As press you should know that there is a difference from reporting on the mob to going inside the mob. Deal with your citation, you made a choice to move in front of the police line and make the mob one person larger.
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 11:25 am
I have been to several protests and gathering this week, i live a few blocks from the Capitol. I have seen lots of police and lots of people but I have not personally witnessed even one person being arrested. The reason is that I , like most grown-ups, am well aware of the ins and outs of avoiding teargas and handcuffs as well as effective means of creating social change. Taunting police and creating a danger for the surrounding community are not on either of those lists.
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 11:39 am
If the American patriots in 1775-1776 had played it as you suggest, we'd still be under the British Crown.
I suggest you read the Constitution od the USA.
I am sure there were some troublemakers, but the right to assembly and freedom of speech is a lot more important than always pleasing the police. After all, I'd like to think we do not live in a police state.
In any case, and before you stake your claim that there is no need to support the rights of troublemakers, remember what Rev. Martin Niemoller said in WWII: “Then they came for me – and by that time there was nobody left to speak up.”
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 12:09 pm
I staked no such claim at all, and we are far from under attack by foreign dictators. The St Paul police are neither local dictators either. I am well versed in the constitution and the progress of World War 2. You offend the survivors and their relatives by comparing protesters to Holocaust victims.
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 12:59 pm
The reference to Niemoller was not to holocaust survivors but to the “good Germans” who silently watched Communists, Jews, dissenters and other “troublemakers” get pcked up one by one by the Nazi regime and sent to concentration camps. It seems we have many “good Germans” like you in our midst today who think, Oh, it can't happen here” just as it is happening before their eyes. It's the worst and most inexcusable sort of denial.
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 1:13 pm
Where are the camps? Where are the mass murders? Where is the holocaust? And before you point to Gitmo as an example of a camp, was even one of these protestors sent there?
It doesn't matter if “it can't happen here” or if it can because, to be frank, it's not. Stop trying to raise hell and read up on history and godwin's law.
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 2:19 pm
If it doesn't matter if it can happen here, we should likewise not concern ourselves with the second amendment. The government is not using deadly force against its own citizens, and we are not under attack, so why do ordinary people need the right to carry a gun? Contrary to popular belief, the second ammendment does not guarantee the right to go hunting.
The point is that it starts with the small things. It is totally a matter of if it can or can't happen here.
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 2:40 pm
You're reading too much into jonerik's comment about Niemoller. He didn't say this is just like Nazi Germany. The principle Niemoller referred to could be applied to any situaiton where oppression is tolerated because it happens to people who are different from us. I made my decision to join the big march on Monday because of the raids over the weekend. The people arrested are mostly different from me since I'm not a young adult nor a journalist, but applying Neimoller's principle, I still spoke up. No, something like Nazi Germany won't happen here, but only because enough of us won't tolerate a police state.
Maybe a similar quote from someone not connected to the Nazi era would avoid bringing in the stigma that goes with Nazi references, because there have been plenty of dictatorships and even dictatorial moments in democracies. Sorry, I don't know a similar quote offhand. I fully recognize that oppression of an unpopular group doesn't necessarily lead to such oppression for everybody, but that's only because enough of us stop it early.
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 2:43 pm
To add on more point, the reference to journalists and legal observers being separated shows that the police could in fact tell journalists from demonstrators. Given the large numbers of journalists arrested or maced, it appears police chose not to tell them apart. Could they even have been targeting journalists?
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 4:37 pm
Perhaps something from Jesus is as far as we can get from Nazis, about 1900 years before (or will we get attacked for naming Jesus by the right wing Jesus police?):
(from http://susanjoan.wordpress.com/2008/04/22/what-...)
'The message Jesus tried to convey to his disciples through the judgment parable in Matthew 25. Jesus tells those who will be saved: when I was hungry, you fed me; … when I was in prison you visited me. When those saved ask him in confusion when they did any of those good things, the response is: “whatever you did for the least brothers of mine, you did for me.” What determines whether one will be saved is: did you recognize Christ in the face of those in need and respond to that need. '
In this case, the people in need were those having their rights violated and I applaud your decision to step in for your fellow citizens. Wouldn't it be nice if more people in this Country had values like those that Jesus Christ taught us?
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 10:37 pm
my friends dog was shot killed by thoughs motherfuckers in riot gear on the 4th another dog went blind and my friend is in the hospital with injuries to her ribs an wrist they were not even envolved with any of the protests
Comment posted September 5, 2008 @ 11:22 pm
Are you serious? Tell that to the families of the college students locked inside their building while some out-of-control lunatic blew them away. If even one person in the building were allowed a gun – student, faculty, security or all of the above – there would have likely been much less life lost. An armed society is a polite society. Increasing access of the colonials to firearms was as central to the success of the American Revolution as the very ideals that brought it about.
Comment posted September 6, 2008 @ 6:42 am
My partner and I were on our way to Great Waters Brewing Co. on Thursday afternoon about 4pm. This is not a special trip by any means in that a number of folks from my office in Wells Fargo Plaza frequent the establishment every week.
As we live in the Summit Hill neighborhood I was aware of the detour into downtown along John Ireland Blvd. yet I chose 94 to 10th street. I was surprised to find 10th street now closed so I opted for Marion to follow the designated detour into downtown. 10th street is the exit for St. Joseph’s hospital by the way for those unfamiliar with the area; I know this route in my sleep it’s where my 4mo old daughter was born. Following the detour signs up Marion towards University we passed what appeared to be a growing number of police gearing up for something exciting. As we approached University we were buzzed by police lights and horns leading minivans, police and sirens escorting a Chippewa Springs water truck. Well heck, we must be going the right way!
As we crawled around the corner onto University and neared the capital I recalled the route via John Ireland and decided to naively attempt a bypass along the western edge of the capital grounds on MLK. The road was open I figured what the heck, the worst that could happen is more time on detoured roads right? As I cleared the capital and neared John Ireland where I intended to make a right turn, I was met with barking commands from the capital lawn “Sir, U-Turn here now! Sir, U-Turn now!” Wasn’t aware I was the target mind you so it took several times for the State Patrol officer to gain my attention. When I discovered I was the intended audience, I U-Turned left and headed back towards University. This is where I grew very concerned. The officer proceeded to block other traffic in my mirrors. Looking right we could watch waves of riot gear laden officers marching down the lawn towards 94. Ok, maybe not a good place to be with my partner and 4mo old daughter? However we are residents of Saint Paul, residents of Minnesota, residents of the US, we have every right to be here. My only choice was a right turn on University, it was now closed to the west! I proceeded with several hundred others along the ordained detour to downtown. Traveling south towards the bridge over 94, imagine my excitement when finding a wall of overcharged men in riot gear blocking the bridge from cars or pedestrians. At to this, snow plows were on the streets in August!
The only option to turn right on 12th street at this point I did so, along with many other vehicles. We haven’t heard any commotion and have only seen several hundred officers in polished gear marshalling across the lawn in formation and lined up on each of the bridges across 94. Walls of riot gear, temporary fencing and Snow Plows blocked bridges across 94 into downtown and roads north away from the scene. I was growing very concerned with this from several perspectives. We had two choices to exit from here. A snow plow on Rice street at the point of determination, 35e south or 94 west as we watched pedestrians try to cross bridges on foot being denied I wondered if any of them would care to walk 35e or 94 themselves.
When we made our destination there was one noticeable difference from the patio at GW, less traffic on St. Peter. The same “Repent or Perish” truck circling the block, I was hoping someone would give him better speakers the sound quality from his PA system and music was just awful. For a couple of hours we could see the plow trucks parked on the bridge over 94, wondering if we would ever get to see a protest march. Guess not tonight, the sheriff has determined enough’s enough? It has been written several places and I agree. The folks determined to march from the capital where herded like cattle along side countless pedestrians. With such force that one could only imagine how much fear could be generated. You stir up enough fear in someone, and now you have yourself an angry participant.
After watching several days of men in blue on bikes circling the blocks in formation, fire engines racing down St. Peter with lights and sirens only to circle back again without emergency and impatiently squawk pedestrians out of cross walks, puffy men in and out of minivans, herds of horses crappin on the grass, coast guard boats darting around outside the Science Museum, National Guard troops haphazardly controlling traffic outside Mickey’s diner netting a maroon Buick a T-Bone after work one day, spotters and rifles on roof tops, building security guards morphing into manly men all over down town, far too many well armed people stone faced looking for a reason, I am glad it’s over. Clean up my city and get out! I can only hope the hordes of people who suffered greater inconvenience through detention or a knee in the neck have their chance to be heard. If not the intended audience on the streets of Saint Paul along with attendees to the RNC, I hope they get their chance in court.
Blanketing the news with recycled stories of poop in bags, items that “could be used” to make Molotov cocktails or topple horses or blow out tires to promote a concept equalizing threat and force is right out of the book of Rove.
Comment posted September 6, 2008 @ 12:53 pm
FREE PAUL'S PENS!!
Comment posted September 6, 2008 @ 11:37 pm
I think Chief Harrington addresses this issue very well in this interview; http://minnesota.publicradio.org/www_publicradi...
Comment posted September 7, 2008 @ 1:22 pm
i completely agree…i was one of the unfortunate many to be arrested……i saw no violence…the only violence i saw was on part of the police tazoring….tear gasing and masing……i personally witnessed a girl have an asthma attack and the police doing nothing for at least 10-15 minutes while we screamed and pleaded for help it wasn't until it came to a man taking his hands of his head picking her up and trying to escort her to them…they tackled them both right at my feet, arresting him and FINALLY taking her to the ambulance……..she could have died……also when i was in jail i asked for my one phone call and the guy said “yeah sure” and shut the door….i never got the phone call and my parents weren't contacted until the next day……they herded people like cattle…….it was chaos and it could have all been avoided if the police had let people just go home……
Comment posted September 11, 2008 @ 12:59 am
Get a grip! First, I was there and saw no one taunt the cops. However, the cops totally crushed all dissent, starting with Fletcher pulling the protest permit at the last minute. What harm would it have caused to allow this peaceful but powerful march to go through the supposed “free speech zone” (more like a speech-free zone)? Apparently, Fletcher & Co. were so hellbent on pleasing their federal masters and kissing the collective ass of the RNC that they were willing to forsake the Constitution. For this, he should be forced out of office.
Secondly, there was no good way to get out. Cops were barking out all kinds of conflicting orders–first sending people west, then bombing the area they were sending people to, then sending people east into another volley of bombs. I personally tried my best to scramble to the other side of the Sears parking lot to the safety of my car but was nearly trampled by horses and forced back into the panicked crowd by cops on bikes who blocked my path.
I've been a political activist and community organizer (unpaid–I also hold down a conventional job) for 30+ years. What I saw of police conduct over the last two weeks is the most repressive I have ever seen or experienced–and I've been to Northern Ireland twice and was in Dublin on the day Bobbie Sands died. Cops in that situation acted with great restraint by comparison.
Civil rights protesters were subjected to vicious police brutality including beatings, sprays from high-powered fire hoses and mauling by dogs. Is it because they were not “grown ups” like you? Did their protests–also claimed to be illegal by racist cops–not create social change? Did Rosa Parks “taunt police” by refusing to sit in the back of the bus?
RSS feed for comments on this post.
Leave a comment