McCollum blasts GOP plan to defund women’s health services
Thursday, February 24, 2011 at 2:46 pm
“Dumb.” That’s how Rep. Betty McCollum characterized proposed cuts to federal family planning funding and a Republican effort to defund Planned Parenthood. At a St. Paul Planned Parenthood clinic Thursday, she also noted that Republicans refused to cut Pentagon funding for NASCAR, but remain adamant about cuts she says could have devastating effects for Minnesota women and children.
Planned Parenthood of Minnesota, North Dakota, South Dakota president Sarah Stoesz introduced McCollum at the press event.
“It’s a challenging time for women’s health and for all of us who care about women in this country,” she said. “We’ve been under quite an attack,” referencing conservative bloggers’ campaign against the health care nonprofit as well as congressional actions to bar federal funds from going to its clinics.
“We do provide abortion services — that’s true we do — it’s about 5 percent of what we do, but primarily what we do is protect the lives and health of women,” she said.
To underscore that point, a clinic patient told the story of her sister, who lives in rural Minnesota near Mankato and whose life she says was saved by the health care group.
“Planned Parenthood is the reason my sister’s cervical cancer was found early and treated successfully,” she said. “My sister’s story has a very happy ending because of Planned Parenthood.”
GOP budget cuts in the U.S. House would eliminate federal Title X funding, a part of which helps support cancer screenings at clinics such as Planned Parenhood’s.
“Who would have though that we would have to be concerned about women’s reproductive rights, women’s rights in 2011 in America,” she said.
She said that the proposed cuts and calls to defund Planned Parenthood involve debates over abortion, but the services of Planned Parenthood are much broader.
“Yes, there are needed at times — it should be extremely rare and in a moment of difficult emotional crisis for women — to look at having an abortion, but that’s 5 percent of what Planned Parenthood does,” said McCollum.
“Ninety-five percent of what Planned Parenthood does is the first line of defense in women’s reproductive health and total overall health,” she added.
She continued, “We can make smart cuts or we can make dumb cuts — and cutting Title X is a dumb cut.”
In the Republicans’ proposed budget, Title X funding would be completely slashed from the federal budget, and those funds are used for health care screenings for women and birth control services. Under federal law, the funds cannot go to abortion services.
Republicans targeting WIC as well
The GOP is also proposing cuts to the Women, Infants and Children (WIC) nutrition program.
“We heard defense spending was off the table, that we could not cut defense spending, but what the House decided we needed were two different engines for one piece of military equipment and that we had to protect the military’s ability to purchase decals for NASCARs,” she said.
“I think there’s room to cut in the Pentagon. There should be room for children, and women who are expecting, to have access to basic nutrition in the United States of America.”
McCollum has been a major force in trying to cut NASCAR funding from the federal budget, a cause that resulted in death threats being sent to her office.
“And they are talking about more cuts,” she continued, adding that a government shutdown is looming. “No more of these stupid, dumb cuts that are going to hurt women, hurt families, and hurt communities. It’s so foolish to even talk about cutting nutrition for women who are either nursing or preparing to deliver a child.”
McCollum, who recently visited Yemen where citizens are calling for Democratic reforms and more rights for women, said she spoke with people who were surprised by Republicans’ plans to cut programs for women and children.
“When they pick up the paper and read that we are cutting it off, they said, ‘This isn’t the America we know,’” she said.
Ultimately, she said that the majority of Americans support Title X programs — even Republicans.
“There are a lot of Republicans and independents that support access to mammographies, cervical cancer screenings and ensuring families can plan by having access to birth control,” she said.
“We can’t let a small group of people hold us hostage on the way forward in the United States.”
12 Comments
Comment posted February 24, 2011 @ 3:05 pm
The republicans are targeting the most vulnerable in our society. This is disgusting and needs to stop. These actions are wealth discrimination. They are giving massive tax breaks to ultra wealthy that have benefitted from living in our society and they pay for those cuts by taking from the needy. What a christian thing to do. We all need to stand in solidarity and run these Tea Bags out of office as soon as possible. They WILL destroy America.
Comment posted February 24, 2011 @ 3:06 pm
Dumb? Sorry Rep. McCollum. Dumb only exists in the real world, not that of religious fundamentalists. The American Taliban develop their policies based on myth, hyperbole and magic. No truth to muddy the process. Besides, nutrition programs and breastfeeding make for healthier babies. How can a Christian support that?
Praise Jebus, God hates liberal babies, Amen.
Comment posted February 24, 2011 @ 5:03 pm
Nice “do,” Betty. You ain’t no Michele Bachmann, that’s for sure. lol
Comment posted February 24, 2011 @ 6:30 pm
Dennis – You finally got something right.
Comment posted February 25, 2011 @ 6:47 am
Have you no decency, sir? Have you, at long last, no decency?
Seriously. You were halfway credible talking about nuclear power and that was less than six weeks ago. You have since degenerated (or more to the point, re-degenerated) into a lower primate flinging feces at anyone who doesn’t agree with your priorities.
Pingback posted February 25, 2011 @ 11:01 am
[...] the rest here: McCollum blasts GOP plan to defund women's health services … Comments [...]
Comment posted February 25, 2011 @ 11:46 am
If your goal is to benefit the Nascar folks and their rich corporate funders, it makes perfect sense to cut the funding that will impact the poor. Poor women don’t buy cars or use Godaddy.com!
God Bless the pro-life Republicans! Church and State forever!
Comment posted February 25, 2011 @ 8:48 pm
I voted for Betty because I knew I could count on her to work for the living, breathing citizens of her district and the country.
Keep it up, Rep. McCollum!
Comment posted March 1, 2011 @ 11:58 am
National Defense is BS! The amount of money spent for an army that is better trained, funded, and (for the most part) equipped than any army in the world could easily pay for every man, woman, and child to have decent healthcare and education. However, the money to be made isn’t as good as killing people with cool technology. We need to stop trying to save money by hurting the ones who need it, and helping those who don”t. Don’t cut social safety nets, cut the weapons programs that make billion dollar airplanes for fighting against aircraft that have no shot.
Lets get this clear, I am not opposed to national defense, but we are in two wars; one against a country that harbored people that attacked us—for the most part I agree with this one. Two we are at war with a country that had nothing to do with said attack. These wars cost us billions of dollars, yet we could care less about our own people? WHY?
Comment posted March 2, 2011 @ 2:35 am
When are women going to wake up to the fact that we are under attack from these cretins? Not only do they believe we don’t have the capacity to make our own responsible decisions through our reproductive years, but then they want to take away the health services so many women depend on as well as the access to affordable birth control. And I am not talking about abortions as birth control. Anyone with any kind of sense would realize that a woman who can’t afford to pay for their birth control can’t afford to pay for a child being born and raised. Not to mention the fact that with successful birth control, abortions are rarely needed. I have known many women who needed the services of Planned Parenthood for their health. When you can’t afford to go to the doctor and you don’t have health insurance, having a place like Planned Parenthood is not just a necessity but an absolute life saver for women. Who would have guessed how much the right wing GOP hates women? No matter what kind of lip service they give, their actions prove they are out to get us. I guess they’ll be happy to see more women suffer because they can’t get the help they need. If you aren’t rich- you’re nothing to them.
Comment posted April 10, 2011 @ 7:03 am
Rep. Betty McCollum has done more for the people of Minnesota and the United States of America, then Rep Michelle Bachmann, Rep. John Kline, Ex-Governor Tim Pawlenty and yes even Sarah Palin COMBINED! She (McCullom) is a Good, True American and I call that patriotism!
RSS feed for comments on this post.
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.







